Rank These Goat Talents by Team Success

[GMR]

I don't discount it, the Red Wings had a legit dynasty with Howe. I'm just saying if we are going solely on the purpose of this thread I think you have to say Howe certainly had the opportunity to win more Cups than Orr. Definitely more time. There were anywhere from 12-18 teams during Orr's career. Both players could have won more Cups, but I think if you had to pick one to penalize more it is Howe.

Fair enough, but I thought this thread was talking about actual team accomplishments. Thus, the reasons for why Player A won more Cups than Player B aren't as relevant.