It's funny, I loved the Liberties as a kid, blue and especially the white ones, then I met some older fans who were laughing that I had bought one for myself because they were so ugly and not a 'real' NYR logo. I remember ppl on here absolutely ripping them too for quite a while, but now they're 'vintage' and it seems most have come around. Or maybe the population here has gotten younger and loved them too as kids.
Regarding these new 3rds, I liked them before last night but thought the logo looked over-sized and weird in the pics. On the ice and on the players though it looked absolutely fine, 8/10. I think 1 out of 3 liking it is pretty fair for an O6 team new look/style jersey.