Well, that's a little tough.
Nanne had the heart infection, missing an entire year, and then had to sit out a year transferring from OSU to Minnesota to be closer to home. So, he never really had a chance.
Fogarty went into the BCHL with a reputation as an offensive guy who played no defense. He left with the reputation as a shut-down, defensive-type. That was probably good for him as the offense he had didn't translate to NCAA hockey at all, really. Without developing his defensive game he might have fallen off the map completely. Also, Notre Dame was who wanted him to play in the BCHL since they didn't think he was ready straight out of high school and were probably right, based on how things developed.
So, for me, Nanne gets a total pass given his circumstances, the D+1 BCHL season worked out fairly well for Fogarty, and Huska seems on a good path. JMO.