Lindbum was the first goalie off the board his draft year and I don't think it was terribly controversial. If I were to have picked one of the goalies, it would have been Skarek as I've said a few times, but Lindbom going first wasn't a huge surprise. I think most rankings had him as one of the top three or four guys at the position, and with goalies it's kind of a guessing game as to when they'll go. IIRC the consensus was that they were more like third-round guys, and the Rangers reached a bit for the one they liked best. Lindbum as the first off the board wasn't a huge surprise, it was more when he was taken (and maybe by whom).I'm talking about at the draft, not what they've done since.
If I was given a choice of either one in their draft year, I would have taken Garand.
Lindbom only had a strong international record to his credit, while Garand was expected to be one of the top goalies in the WHL in his D+1 season.
Beside Askarov, there were other guys like Commesso, Daws, Blowqvist, Bednar and a few others that were usually ahead of Garand. He was more in the 5-7 range of ranked goalies in his draft, though his draft was also better.
Though I will say, looking across drafts, Garand at 103 is a dramatically better value than Lindbum at 39, IMO, even if you really liked Lindbum that year.