Question About the Zub Hit on Tavares

[TheDoldrums]

you don't miss a significant amount of OT time when you're diving you proles

 

[Golden_Jet]

you don't miss a significant amount of OT time when you're diving you proles

Yes you do, when you’ve been called into concussion protocol for staying down so long, and only getting up, when the play has left the zone.

Which now groups you in with the rest of us working class proles.

 

[koteka]

So several years ago you thought he was good (maybe at around age 26-27) but now that he's 34 you're realizing he isn't as good?

Seems to track.

More like the Islanders got much better when he left and Toronto couldn’t win playoff games:

2016-2017 Islanders miss playoffs
2017-2018 Islanders miss playoffs
— Tavares leaves and the Islanders are doomed —
2018-2019 Islanders make playoffs and win in the first round, meanwhile Toronto loses in the first round
2019-2020 Islanders lose Conference finals, meanwhile Toronto loses in the play in round
2020-2021 Islanders barely lose Conference finals in 7 games, meanwhile Toronto loses in the first round

Tavares was still in his prime for those losses and he had 4 goals and 4 assists in 12 games while carrying an $11 million cap hit and earning $43.9 million.

 

[TheDoldrums]

Yes you do, when you’ve been called into concussion protocol for staying down so long, and only getting up, when the play has left the zone.

Which now groups you in with the rest of us working class proles.

I’ve seen players leave concussion protocol in the regular season faster than Tavares did. If there was nothing to check he would have been out there much quicker.

 

[conFABulator]

can still be penalized or reviewed for discipline.
1. They don't have to review it.
2. They don't have to tell you that they did review it and deemed it not worth of supplemental discipline.

Would you be okay with them reviewing it but not telling you?

Thanks, I understand and agree with both points. I am also not saying it deserves supplementary discipline. It was likely a missed penalty and I was surprised there wasn't more about it given the impact it had on the game

 

[conFABulator]

If a player puts himself in a position where he receives head contact because of the positioning of his body made head contact unavoidable, the league won't suspend a player and rarely a penalty is called. We've seen this many times and it's in the rulebook.

Understood, it is also true that even if the offender "didn't mean to" they can still be penalized. This is why I thought there might be a review and discussion about that.

 

[Kegu]

Thanks, I understand and agree with both points. I am also not saying it deserves supplementary discipline. It was likely a missed penalty and I was surprised there wasn't more about it given the impact it had on the game

Because it really wasn't much of a play, and this thread encapsulates it perfectly. If it was more than it was the usual suspects would be in here ranting and raving to the end of the earth, and i guarantee you the thread would have been up the minute the hit happened.

 

[Mattb124]

That is a penalty - elbow very clearly came out intentionally, but these are the playoffs.

 

[KevinRedkey]

It probably could have been a penalty (on Zub), but I can also see why it wasn't. It certainly wasn't blatant or reckless by either player IMO .It was a weird play.. thus the thread I guess.

Consensus in here (aside from a few homers) seems to be that as well.

 

[conFABulator]

Because it really wasn't much of a play, and this thread encapsulates it perfectly. If it was more than it was the usual suspects would be in here ranting and raving to the end of the earth, and i guarantee you the thread would have been up the minute the hit happened.

Thanks again, I have found this to be useful for me too. I truly wanted feedback from many sources. I try not to be a homer but there are always many ways to view the same play and the prevailing opinion (not the ones coming from either end of the spectrum) is -- yes, by the book this was technically an illegal play and MAY have been worthy of two minutes, maybe. However it was missed, or playoffs, or whatever and it was not worthy or review or suspension. I can agree with and live with that.