Not bad, not bad.
Boston’s design is fine, and I like the icy color scheme, but the logo is mostly “hollow” so it seems to blend into the background. They need a filled-in version of the logo which will pop more.
Montreal is a case of an ugly logo which makes a great crest on a jersey. Overall this is one of the better new pro hockey jerseys I’ve seen lately, nice proportions and color balance to create a unique look.
New York reminds me of a 90s minor league team. Not my personal favorite aesthetic, but it’s a high quality example of that aesthetic.
Minnesota… I would show this jersey to a class of design students to explain how NOT to design a hockey logo. This logo flat-out cannot be effective as a jersey crest. It leaves a weird amount of white space and throws the whole torso off-center. This is a bad, bad look for that reason alone.
Ottawa seems generic, and I hate gray lettering on a dark background. But otherwise it’s inoffensive. They need a less generic logo to take it up a notch.
Toronto’s blue is the best of the bunch. The promo video does a great job of showing how this can be worn as streetwear under a jacket and come off really nicely. I’m a big fan of this color combo.
Overall this is a strong aesthetic rollout for them. I appreciate that they stuck to the fundamentals and used a traditional template, and used interesting colors and shapes to create something new. This feels like it was made by hockey fans for hockey fans.