Power Rank the Last 8 Goaltenders

[Synergy27]

As a Ranger fan, the only guy over which I feel like we don’t have an advantage in net is Swayman. Take that as you may.

 

[BelovedIsles]

Right now, Swayman, Otter 2nd. Perhaps Swayman puts in a JS Giguere performance and carries the B's to the Cup.

 

[SeanMoneyHands]

Swayman

Everyone else. Swayman is in the zone and is putting up a J.S. Giguere run. Will see if his performance is sustainable. He may run out of gas.

There this years goalie that catches fire, Swayman.

 

[Bleedred]

Shesterkin
Swayman

(Demko*)
Bobrovsky
Skinner
Oettinger

Georgiev

Andersen
(DeSmith/Silovs*)

 

[SnowblindNYR]

Right now, Swayman, Otter 2nd. Perhaps Swayman puts in a JS Giguere performance and carries the B's to the Cup.

Otter is second? He has a 0.915 save percentage to Shesterkin's 0.929 save percentage. Shesterkin also has a 0.929 CAREER playoff save percentage to Otter's 0.918. I know you're an Islanders fan, but c'mon man.

 

[Satire]

Tier 1: Shesterkin, Swayman, Bobrovsky, Demko
Tier 2: Andersen, Oettenger
Tier 3: Skinner, D
Tier 4: Georgiev
I won’t rank Silovs because the sample size is too small. But he looks like he could be the back up next year and we’ll get a better handle on him. So far he’s been great.

I think this list is fair. I might out Andersen in tier 3, but he's also one of those guys that can go on a run too. I think we all know Oettinger is capable of being in tier 1, but he's been a bit inconsistent so far this playoffs.

 

[cgf]

Tier 1. Goalie playing behind the Avs
Tier 2. Goalie playing against the Avs

 

[The S5]

Right now, Swayman, Otter 2nd. Perhaps Swayman puts in a JS Giguere performance and carries the B's to the Cup.

Hater.

 

[FlameChampion]

Shersterkin/Swayman/Demko

Oettinger/Bobrovsky

Andersen/Skinner/Georgeiv

Not Ranked: Silovs

For me

 

[clmetsfan]

Silovs was top 5 on a lot of goalie prospect lists before the season started
He's a big agile goalie that has studied under the best goaltending coach in the world since the day he was drafted - don't underestimate his ability to steal a bunch of games in a short tournament format.

Benoit Allaire doesn't coach for the Canucks.

 

[Ezekial]

Based on how they are playing at this moment:
Swayman
Igor
Bob
Freddy
Otter
Skinner/Georgiev/Slivos (hard to rank him rn i think he's played well but not enough sample size to put him solidly above anyone)

 

[Perfect_Drug]

Bob/Shesterkin/Swayman
Anderson
Demko
Oettinger/Georgiev/Skinner/Silvos (if needed)

East have the top 4.. .from a west fan

They also have the most impotent offences that don't get a steady diet of MacKinnon / McDavid.

 

[HockeyWooot]

Shesterkin
Bobrovsky
Swayman
Oettinger
Andersen
Skinner
Silovs
Georgiev

 

[SImpelton]

Right now, Swayman, Otter 2nd. Perhaps Swayman puts in a JS Giguere performance and carries the B's to the Cup.

If you're a B's fan it's called a Tim Thomas performance because that's the last guy to do it here.

And yeah, there's definitely some comparisons going on between the two American goaltenders born 3 decades apart, on the B's forum.

 

[triggrman]

I think a lot are selling Silovs short becuase he's young.

 

[Zenos]

Lmao at Demko/Silovs combo being lower than sieves like Georgiev and goalies like Skinner Demko is a vezina nominee


I take Silovs who shut out Preds to win the series ahead of Georgiev and Skinner

Relax. One is injured and may not even play again these playoffs, while the other was an emergency call-up.

A healthy Demko would definitely slot higher in most people's list.

 

[WarriorofTime]

I think a lot are selling Silovs short becuase he's young.

He may have a good career, but if I'm picking right now, going with a young kid from the AHL is too risky for me

 

[triggrman]

He may have a good career, but if I'm picking right now, going with a young kid from the AHL is too risky for me

fair

 

[ViD]

Elite:
Shestyorkin

Very good:
Swayman
Bobrovsky

Good:
Oettinger
Georgiev
Andersen

Average
Skinner

Below average
Silovs

 

[BCNate]

Tier 1: Shesterkin, Swayman, Bobrovsky, Oettinger, Demko
Tier 2: Andersen
Tier 3: Skinner
Tier AHL: Georgiev, Silovs

I’d make a junior college hockey tier and put Skinner in that one.

 

[jackjohnson]

Elite:
Shestyorkin

Very good:
Swayman
Bobrovsky

Good:
Oettinger
Georgiev
Andersen

Average
Skinner

Below average
Silovs

Canucks with below average goalie still beat the Oilers

 

[WarriorofTime]

I think you gotta move Skinner down after last night. That was a very bad performance.

 

[SnowblindNYR]

Elite:
Shestyorkin

Very good:
Swayman
Bobrovsky

Good:
Oettinger
Georgiev
Andersen

Average
Skinner

Below average
Silovs

Georgiev is good? I know he played in Russia so you love him but come on.

 

[deckercky]

Healthy bubble Demko is probably number 1 imo. People here sleeping on Demko

The bubble was a loooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooong time ago.

 

[ViD]

Georgiev is good? I know he played in Russia so you love him but come on.

His regular season and play off career SV% are both .908, that is good in my books