1 M.Celebrini
2 C.Eiserman
3 A.Kiviharju
4 I.Demidov
5 B.Catton
6 M.Massé
7 B.Sennecke
8 C.Hutson
9 K.Helenius
10 R.Ritchie
11 A.Levshunov
12 C.Lindstrom
13 Z.Parekh
14 C.Yakemchuk
15 C.Humphreys
16 D.Badinka
17 S.Boisvert
18 A.Jiricek
19 H.Mews
20 T.Howe
21 S.Dickinson
22 E.Hemming
23 A.Shen
24 T.Lavoie
25 Y.Surin
26 J.Parsons
27 W.Skahan
28 L.Greentree
29 A.Cristoforo
30 K.Bednarik
31 E.Emery
32 K.Sterner
1. Celebrini (1) Rate : A
He was a sure value as a center who had already proven himself
2. Eiserman (9) Rate : B
I thought it was just a matter of position but his pick in 2 last year was inevitable
3. Kiviharju (64) Rate : F
I clung to hope for a long time with this former child prodigy. It was an error
4. Demidov (2) Rate : B
I saw him as a Michkov, a little less talented but more defensive. It seemed like a top 5 out of. Only B because Kiviharju in front.
5. Catton (8) Rate : A
It was a choice from last year but in 5 with a small size, I anticipated a big season which would affirm him as the best Canadian offensive talent born in 2006. Which he is.
6. Masse (41) Rate : D
I wasn't convinced by his positioning in 6 - he could have been between 10 and 15 but he was the guy who had proven the most in U17. Skating should have condemned him to this position 6.
7. Sennecke (16) Rate : A
I have always been hot on this player as a defensive end with offensive skills. He will likely be drafted higher than his current roster spot. It wasn't easy to have him in 7.
8. Hutson (46) Rate : D
I got carried away by his brother's fever and the fact that he was already older. But he's not talented enough to be what I thought he was going to be.
9. Helenius (13) Rate : A
That's what I call hitting the nail on the head. I moved it down a few places in my last list from a slightly disappointing U18 tournament but it's exactly what I expected last year.
10. Ritchie (54) Rate : D
I am correct with the initial choice in relation to the context of the time but its fall is still big. I would have rated myself a C if it had been ranked a few ranks lower.
11. Levshunov (3) Rate : B
I wanted to be careful about a side commitment (promotion of Belarusian prospects) and avoid being burdened by detractors. I should have ranked him higher.
12. Lindstrom (4) Rate : A
It was very difficult to have it higher last year and part of me thinks I have it too high now.
13. Parekh (7) Rate : A
He is a little stronger than I thought but the qualities and faults perceived last year have not changed.
14. Yakemchuk (11) Rate : A
I moved it up two ranks recently. Its evolution corresponds exactly to my idea last year.
15. Humphreys (98) Rate : D
It was a gamble because I thought USDP prospects would go up like previous years. Still in my top 100 so D.
16. Badinka (37) Rate : A
He might be drafted around 20. Having him in the 1st round in 2023 was unpredictable. I think I was the first to take the risk by experiencing a big storm. It's A for context.
17. Boisvert (22) Rate : A
Very good evaluation of his potential physical center which attracts scouts.
18. Jiricek (26) Rate : A
I had him much lower than usual lists and I don't think he would be any higher on my current list without the injury. Perhaps even the opposite paradoxically. Still overrated for me.
19. Mews (23) Rate : A
Compared to my idea of the player at the time and today which is similar, I rate myself at A. I think he is very underrated.
20. Howe (32) Rate : A
I pretty much expected this kind of position. He may very well be selected at this rank in 10 days.
21. Dickinson (5) Rate : C
I quickly changed my opinion at the start of the season. He had slipped on my list so as not to favor CHL players too much. I would have given it a D if there had been a disgusting name among the defenders.
22. Hemming (20) Rate : A
Exactly the same opinion. I think he's slightly underrated. I have always classified him by comparing with Helenius.
23. Shen (NC) Rate : F
Big failure for me because I saw him as the best Russian before 2006 with Surin. I haven't seen Artamonov or Chernyshov for 2024. Shame.
24. Lavoie (75) Rate : C
Big right-handed defender with No. 1 Q status, I thought he was going to establish himself as a defender of choice at the end of the 1st round due to his rare profile. It was very difficult to find other names at this rank last year.
25. Surin (38) Rate : B
He is rising a lot in the current lists but considering that I missed two other Russian attackers, A is not deserved.
26. Parsons (NC) Rate : F
Completely stupid 2023 pick like Rastislav Elias in 2021. I was looking to put a goalie and he is very far from being in my top 25 goalies now.
27. Skahan (42) Rate : B
I still saw him with greater offensive potential. In the context of the time, it was a sure bet in 27 (it doesn't sting the eyes)
28. Greentree (14) Rate : A
He is placed around this position in many lists. I have him even higher now.
29. Cristoforo (NC) Rate : D
Other guys have taken a bite out of this player's offensive potential. So D rather than F.
30. Bednarik (57) Rate : A
He can come out very well in this position. I imagined him as a John Beecher. But I rate it lower and last year that was the case too. He replaced players I expected not to know.
31. Emery (31) Rate : A
Perfect.
32. Sterner (118) Rate : D
I have a soft spot for this player. I had him ranked 32 as a potential defensive player who could explode on offense. This choice does not seem stupid to me