Players with the full hardware case

[ViD]

How many players have won the most important awards at least once in their career ?

Calder Trophy
Hart Memorial Trophy
Art Ross Trophy
Rocket Richard Trophy
Ted Lindsay Award
Stanley Cup
Conn Smythe Trophy

Is Ovechkin really the only one who won all of the above?

Lemieux obviously won all as well but Rocket was first awarded in 99.

Sid missed Calder.

Geno never won a Rocket.

McDavid missed Calder and a SC

 

[SenzZen]

Patty Kane just missing the Rocket, I believe.

 

[Soundwave]

Calder is a nothing trophy IMO, Sid has the full hardware case as far as I'm concerned.

 

[SenzZen]

Patty Kane just missing the Rocket, I believe.

Hold the fort!...

I stand corrected:

 

[Lazytrout]

Calder is a nothing trophy IMO, Sid has the full hardware case as far as I'm concerned.

I agree with this, also he would have won the calder literally any other year. 2nd best rookie season in the 21th century at worst.

 

[Nadal On Clay]

MacKinnon needs Ross/Rocket/Smythe. Probably the one with the best odds to join that club.

 

[max21]

Calder is a nothing trophy IMO, Sid has the full hardware case as far as I'm concerned.

I agree with this, also he would have won the calder literally any other year. 2nd best rookie season in the 21th century at worst.

Good god it’s literally anything to discredit Ovechkin

 

[DearDiary]

Why the Calder and how is it more important than the Selke? McDavid lost it to a 24 year old Panarin. Ovechkin was 2 years older than Crosby.

 

[ViD]

Why the Calder and how is it more important than the Selke? McDavid lost it to a 24 year old Panarin. Ovechkin was 2 years older than Crosby.

Well, I consider Calder an important and unique trophy as you can only win it once

 

[895]

Selke and Calder are both minor trophies.

 

[Coffey]

Hold the fort!...

I stand corrected:

View attachment 995452

In that case, I'm sure he has multiple rockets.

 

[Lazytrout]

Good god it’s literally anything to discredit Ovechkin

Did Ovi win a selke?

I'm a massive Ovechkin fan but you rather assume I'm just glazing Crosby for reasons, stop being so insecure.

 

[Wasted Talent]

Orr? No Rocket but a handful of Norrises to make up for it.

 

[Coffey]

MacKinnon needs Ross/Rocket/Smythe. Probably the one with the best odds to join that club.

With his shot, I'm surprised he's only hit 50+ once and 40+ twice.

 

[Sasha Orlov]

Demidov becomes the next member, bookmark this post

 

[ijuka]

Before reading the thread; "What's a full hardware case?" After reading who's the OP: "Probably defined so that a Russian player is the only one" After reading the OP: "What a shocking development."

Well, I consider Calder an important and unique trophy as you can only win it once

Translation: "This definition allows a Russian to be the only one to fit the definition."

 

[Sky04]

Well, I consider Calder an important and unique trophy as you can only win it once

Then you should also include the Selke so no Ovechkin has not won them all. I consider a strong defensive game from a forward is important so...

 

[jigglysquishy]

Bobby Orr won every trophy he was eligible to win.

 

[max21]

Did Ovi win a selke?

I'm a massive Ovechkin fan but you rather assume I'm just glazing Crosby for reasons, stop being so insecure.

Yeah I’m the one being insecure “he would have won it any other year” but he didn’t because he got beaten by Ovechkin, doesn’t really matter the significance of the trophy.

 

[kingsholygrail]

How many players have won the most important awards at least once in their career ?

Calder Trophy
Hart Memorial Trophy
Art Ross Trophy
Rocket Richard Trophy
Ted Lindsay Award
Stanley Cup
Conn Smythe Trophy

Is Ovechkin really the only one who won all of the above?

Lemieux obviously won all as well but Rocket was first awarded in 99.

Sid missed Calder.

Geno never won a Rocket.

McDavid missed Calder and a SC

No Lady Byng. No Selke.

 

[ViD]

Before reading the thread; "What's a full hardware case?" After reading who's the OP: "Probably defined so that a Russian player is the only one" After reading the OP: "What a shocking development."


Translation: "This definition allows a Russian to be the only one to fit the definition."

Your post literally makes no sense. Is Lemieux a Russian or am I missing something ?

 

[ViD]

Then you should also include the Selke so no Ovechkin has not won them all. I consider a strong defensive game from a forward is important so...

If you add the Selke, that likely means nobody has the full case ?

 

[Nemesis Prime]

Why the Calder and how is it more important than the Selke? McDavid lost it to a 24 year old Panarin. Ovechkin was 2 years older than Crosby.

Arguing Selke is more important over Calder is crazy work.

 

[Sky04]

If you add the Selke, that likely means nobody has the full case ?

Why are we excluding it just because Ovechkin doesn't have one, it's a major award seems like you're just cherry picking. So yes nobody has a full case.

 

[redbeardtx]

Before reading the thread; "What's a full hardware case?" After reading who's the OP: "Probably defined so that a Russian player is the only one" After reading the OP: "What a shocking development."


Translation: "This definition allows a Russian to be the only one to fit the definition."

Like clockwork.