I find it amazing where a sport that demands their players to start to learn how to skate essentially after learning how to walk to have any shot of making the NHL, to be so full of players that were awful skaters. I would think that skating would be the one thing every NHL caliber hockey player would be good at or at least passable. Anyways my contribution would be Corey Perry...Wait no he still sucks at skating never mind.
It’s all relative, though. Mostly, the “bad skaters who become good skaters” are about average skaters at the OHL/WHL/whatever level, so we assume they’ll be well below average skaters in the NHL, as the NHL is a higher bar. Some of them improve a lot though, and become average NHL skaters, or even strong NHL skaters.
BUT, an average OHL/WHL/whatever is still an elite skater for a competitive hockey player, it’s just weak for a “cream of the crop” type that gets drafted into the NHL. “Bad skaters” have skating that’s not quite at the level you’d hope for, for an 18 year old who’s getting drafted by an NHL team - they’re still elite skaters for basically any other cohort.
You look at guys like young Horvat, Draisaitl, Tavares, Rossi, it’s not like they instantly stand out as bad skaters when you watch them. It’s more that, if you really focus on their skating over the course of a game, you notice some shortcomings. Rossi and Tavares didn’t have the bursts of elite acceleration you like to see, Horvat and Daisaitl had somewhat short/choppy strides, etc. But these guys all have/had good enough skating to be outstanding overall players when they got drafted. Bad
FOR A TOP PROSPECT is not actually bad.