Prospect Info: Pittsburgh Penguins Prospects Thread: 2023-2024 Edition

Randy Butternubs

Registered User
Mar 15, 2008
29,816
21,423
Morningside
If you go, would love a posted description of our top prospects’ performances…same for anyone attending the camp

Will do.

One thing I've finally learned after all of these years: take everything with a major grain of salt with the performances in these camps. Don't get too hyped unless a player absolutely blows everyone else out of the water at all aspects of the camp.
 

CheckingLineCenter

Registered User
Aug 10, 2018
8,634
9,199
Will do.

One thing I've finally learned after all of these years: take everything with a major grain of salt with the performances in these camps. Don't get too hyped unless a player absolutely blows everyone else out of the water at all aspects of the camp.
Anyone that dominated and you came out of there feeling like they were a diamond in the rough then turned out to be a dud?
 

Randy Butternubs

Registered User
Mar 15, 2008
29,816
21,423
Morningside
The last 2 dev camps I went were I think 2010 and 2013/14. In 2010 Tangradi was unstoppable and Mattias Modig was a brick wall. And the other Matt Murray gave up every shot he faced while Sean Maguire looked like a Vezina candidate.

Yep. It goes both ways for the "hypes" and "disappointments".

To add, I think people were excited for Ty Glover after one of his camps.
 

steelcityassault

Registered User
Sep 17, 2008
1,276
541
Pittsburgh, PA
The last 2 dev camps I went were I think 2010 and 2013/14. In 2010 Tangradi was unstoppable and Mattias Modig was a brick wall. And the other Matt Murray gave up every shot he faced while Sean Maguire looked like a Vezina candidate.
One year, AHL-lifer Jon D'Aversa outperformed every single person including 1st rounders. Just double checked, never got to play an NHL game. No call-ups either.

Unrelated, I remember hearing story of Ryan Lannon where his only NHL call-up he ended up pissing Therrien off for being drunk after curfew, got healthy scratched and immediately sent down and never made his debut
 

Jacob

as seen on TV
Feb 27, 2002
49,843
25,871
I used to go to these until I realized they were completely useless as far as evaluations.

The worst players will come out flying because they have to to be noticed and the decent prospects will be taking it easy because it's meaningless.
 

SomeDude

Registered User
Mar 6, 2006
17,602
29,198
Pittsburghish
I used to go to these until I realized they were completely useless as far as evaluations.

The worst players will come out flying because they have to to be noticed and the decent prospects will be taking it easy because it's meaningless.

You can still gather information. For instance, I remember going to the 2003 rookie camp and realized the Pens just drafted a 2nd rounder in Johannes Salmonsson that couldn’t skate backwards.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jacob

Jacob

as seen on TV
Feb 27, 2002
49,843
25,871
One year, AHL-lifer Jon D'Aversa outperformed every single person including 1st rounders. Just double checked, never got to play an NHL game. No call-ups either.

Unrelated, I remember hearing story of Ryan Lannon where his only NHL call-up he ended up pissing Therrien off for being drunk after curfew, got healthy scratched and immediately sent down and never made his debut
Do any Oldheads remember the camp Dwight LaBrosse dominated?
 
  • Like
Reactions: steelcityassault

Goodleaf

Love a good stick.
Nov 15, 2010
883
363
One year, AHL-lifer Jon D'Aversa outperformed every single person including 1st rounders. Just double checked, never got to play an NHL game. No call-ups either.

Unrelated, I remember hearing story of Ryan Lannon where his only NHL call-up he ended up pissing Therrien off for being drunk after curfew, got healthy scratched and immediately sent down and never made his debut
That checks out for Lannon. He used to trade "favors" to an older woman and she would write his Harvard papers for him.
Do any Oldheads remember the camp Dwight LaBrosse dominated?
He was the year before I got my drivers license so I missed him. I just remember he was on the long list of swings and misses for Penguin goalie picks. He is from Pittsburgh, so I am just gonna assume he posts here.
 
Last edited:

Turin

Erik Karlsson is good
Feb 27, 2018
23,475
27,478
Just because you don't pick in the top five does not mean you cannot develop a top-five equivalent talent.

To say the players we have let go have not done anything elsewhere is proving my point that we do not develop young players well. Excluding goaltenders, a player is what he is when he is 26. We seem allergic to trying to develop players at the NHL level before that age. Which is crazy, because historically our championships have been won with youth, and of course the right veterans mixed in.

We had an opportunity this off-season to REALLY give some young forwards some hope that they were coming to camp with a legit shot at making the team. It was thought that Eller could be traded, and that Acciari might either be packaged in a deal or move to the wing, freeing up the center positions to see what our top prospects can do.

So what did we do? Knowing full well that our coach is named Mike Sullivan, and that he LOVES low-talent worker bees, we sign Lizotte (who will probably play WAY too much for his talent level), Beauvillier (an absolutely nothing player for years) and trade for a guy who is not even a Sullivan type (save for his birth certificate) in Hayes.

So now, yeah we might trade Eller as we had hoped. But that is because Hayes and Lizotte have to play instead of Ponomarev, Poulin and especially Yager.

Sorry, but this is not how you develop your prospects. If all you want is a bag full of prospects to use as assets, then fantastic. That is what we seem to be doing.

But good teams need ELCs to win. If not, you are hoping that veteran players will come cheaply to your team. Is Pittsburgh an attractive destination for veterans right now?

July 1 and since tells us no.
Or, get this, the Pens haven’t drafted anybody capable of being a good NHLer in 8 years. Stat probability shows that is entirely possible with where they have picked since 2017.
 

Freeptop

Registered User
Jun 17, 2009
2,372
1,255
Pittsburgh, PA
Wish I could go to the scrimmage this year, but it won't work out this time.

I found it interesting to watch the scrimmage to sort of see playing styles, but I agree it's not a great place to evaluate prospects.

On a side note - one thing with the camp having so many ATOs is that I hope they end up signing at least one or two. One of the few sources of young talent the Pens have had during the Crosby years has been from undrafted free agents - Lovejoy, Letestu, Sheary, Aston-Reese, O'Connor, etc. They might not be the best players, but they can end up filling slots in the roster while still on ELCs, when they work out. Last year, the Pens didn't sign any at all. Hopefully, that was just a matter of being in transition with a new GM. I'm hoping they can get back to adding to the prospect pool through that avenue again.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Randy Butternubs

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad