I attempt to avoid getting into people's heads like that whenever possible, but I will say that there was one moment in particular where I wondered if his attention to detail had slipped. This is Claypool's 4th TD in the Steelers game last year.
Claypool's the inside receiver on the near side of the field. They give up a TD and the game's over. Neither Safety has MOF responsibility. That's Nate Gerry on an island.
For all of the complaints about Gerry, the only possible outcome here was him getting burned. That's on the staff. Even an idiot like me knows you have to take the TO there because there are 2 or 3 LBs on the planet who have a prayer of covering an uber athletic NFL WR 1v1 in space after giving him a free release off the line.