Confirmed Trade: - [PHI/TOR] Joseph Woll, Simon Benoit for Emil Andrae, Samuel Ersson, 2026 3rd round pick | Page 28 | HFBoards - NHL Message Board and Forum for National Hockey League

Confirmed Trade: [PHI/TOR] Joseph Woll, Simon Benoit for Emil Andrae, Samuel Ersson, 2026 3rd round pick

  • If you are having issues logging in, we have found opening the log in page in a new tab/window rather than using the pop out should resolve these issues. We are working to get this resolved and thank you for patience.
  • Due to the increased volume of league transactions, the Trade Rumors and Free Agent Talk section is temporarily restricted to where threads may only be started by moderators and sponsors. We anticipate that this restriction will be lifted some time after the first round of the draft.
Who’s holding it against one player ? He was awful last year . Could he bounce back ? Sure but he’s not exactly a high upside guy . Similar calibre of players are available on waivers every year . Just factual .
Hmm never said he was anything more than a good 3rd pairing guy.

Plays D reasonably, zero offence, throws some hits (can pull him out of position) and throws the odd knuckle, prone to trying to do too much when played too many minutes. Can be an effective guy when kept on task on the 3rd pairing, the kind of guy most teams want as their 6/7 Dman.
 
Hmm never said he was anything more than a good 3rd pairing guy.

Plays D reasonably, zero offence, throws some hits (can pull him out of position) and throws the odd knuckle, prone to trying to do too much when played too many minutes. Can be an effective guy when kept on task on the 3rd pairing, the kind of guy most teams want as their 6/7 Dman.
6 / 7 / scratched kind of d . I don’t agree . He’s just a place holder and not a “ good “ defender . Can be physical . That’s the end of the pluses in my view
 
But why did they get a goalie back? Wierd trade.
Going to be the Marlies backup? He's certainly not suiting up for the Leafs.

It's annoying because PuckPedia and CapWages have already switched to next year's calculus, so we don't know where the Flyers currently stand in terms of number of contracts. If they had to ship someone out to stay under the 50 contract limit? Remember, the NHL season officially changes on July 1st. We are still in the 25-26 season by the books.
 
why go for Woll? don't Murashov and the other guy need playing time? it's not like they are contending right now and desperately need another NHL starter
 
why go for Woll? don't Murashov and the other guy need playing time? it's not like they are contending right now and desperately need another NHL starter
Murashov and Blomqvist play for Pittsburgh.

All Philly has is Kolosov, Bjarnasson and Vladar
 
Hates got nothing to do with it. He's just objectively not an effective player. He was less awful the year before. Very very replaceable player. Seems like a likeable enough fellow beyond that.
LOL ok Objective, I think not.

He is replaceable, most players are, him more than most.
 
Hmm never said he was anything more than a good 3rd pairing guy.

Plays D reasonably, zero offence, throws some hits (can pull him out of position) and throws the odd knuckle, prone to trying to do too much when played too many minutes. Can be an effective guy when kept on task on the 3rd pairing, the kind of guy most teams want as their 6/7 Dman.

He’s absolutely not a good 3rd pairing guy. He was the worst Leafs defender by every underlying metric his entire tenure.

He doesn’t play D reasonably, because part of being a defenseman is being able to exit your defensive zone. He can move people out of the front of the net but that is the extent of his defensive abilities.
 
Of all the goalies that played for Toronto this season Hildeby had the best save percentage at .912 and he was the only goalie above a .900 that says he’s atleast backup quality for the NHL even though the wins were not there this season.

Rumours suggesting Leafs eyeing Bobrovsky.

My statement remains, in a non tank season you aren’t tanking, your tandem can’t be Solartz/Hildeby and think your going to make the playoffs in the Atlantic.

Bob coming here would probably make way more sense on why Woll moved (Stolz and Bob won a cup as a tandem) than protecting Hildeby from waivers.

While at first Andrae looked underwhelming, the accounting reports on him have me excited about watching him. If you haven’t, go read some. Increased role in Toronto could do wonders for Andrae, and this kid may be 5’9, but he’s not soft and holds his own - size won’t limit him as much as you think.

This trade is looking better and better, and the notion this was made to clear a roster spot for Hildeby is more laughable by the day.
 
Rumours suggesting Leafs eyeing Bobrovsky.

My statement remains, in a non tank season you aren’t tanking, your tandem can’t be Solartz/Hildeby and think your going to make the playoffs in the Atlantic.

Bob coming here would probably make way more sense on why Woll moved (Stolz and Bob won a cup as a tandem) than protecting Hildeby from waivers.

While at first Andrae looked underwhelming, the accounting reports on him have me excited about watching him. If you haven’t, go read some. Increased role in Toronto could do wonders for Andrae, and this kid may be 5’9, but he’s not soft and holds his own - size won’t limit him as much as you think.

This trade is looking better and better, and the notion this was made to clear a roster spot for Hildeby is more laughable by the day.
I wouldn’t be surprised if Anthony Stolarz is not ready to play at the beginning of next season after that terrible injury at the end of the season, it’s possible Toronto adds another goalie as insurance, at the worst Dennis Hildeby could be a 3rd string but I don’t expect Toronto to carry 3 goalies next season, someone will end up on waivers if both Hildeby and Sam Ersson are in the organization in September.

As a Flyers fan I’ve watched 95% of Philly’s games this season, Emil Andrae is not a flashy defenseman but he’s not underwhelming either, I see Emil’s strengths in his mobility and hockey IQ but what really impressed me his ability to move the puck so quickly and get it to his teammates in an organized manner on their tapes. 🏒

Andrae also showed a willingness to compete throughout the season never backing down despite being undersized and that’s why Flyers fans liked him for that reason, there were a few nights where he had some inconsistency in his games but it was expected for a younger defender with a little over 100 NHL games played coming from overseas.

I believe Andrae could shine in Toronto if he can get some ice time but he’s going to earn it starting during training camp/preseason, Emil also has a knack for getting himself out of trouble on the end walls against aggressive forechecking teams.

I want Simon Benoit to hit someone and stay steady defensively, no need for him to even cross the red line, also need Joseph Woll to stay healthy in Philly, we need more .905 + save percentage seasons from him.

Also sucks losing a 3rd rounder to the Leafs bringing Philly’s picks to only 4 picks in the 26 draft as of now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HavingACow4Cowan
Chayka apparently targeted Andrae and also wanted cap space immediately. And also got a 3rd.
With the value of draft picks tanking in the last 24 hours it might have been a better idea to hold for a bit but we've yet to see another good goalie move so who knows.
 
Chayka apparently targeted Andrae and also wanted cap space immediately. And also got a 3rd.

Yeah, targeting a puny 24yr old offensive defenseman with 20 career points in 107 games seems very much like Toronto media propaganda as usual.

IDK why you (and most other Leafs fans) believe that BS. It was a cap clearing move. Nothing more.
 
Yeah, targeting a puny 24yr old offensive defenseman with 20 career points in 107 games seems very much like Toronto media propaganda as usual.

IDK why you (and most other Leafs fans) believe that BS. It was a cap clearing move. Nothing more.
Andrae is a quality bottom pair player, certainly much better than Benoit.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Ad

Ad