Peter Griffin
Registered User
It’s obvious Tocchet is trying to motivate Pettersson to compete harder. This doesn’t seem to be a case of him trying to convince him to play harder through an injury. That’s silly.
And then, Tocchet would publically call Pettersson, a guy who we just signed to an 8-year-contract, a passenger, knowing that he's injured and it isn't his fault.The team isn’t using illness to cover for another injury to Pettersson, he said.
“We don’t lie here,” he said, with emphasis.
Unprompted, Tocchet said he’s aware that there’s been speculation about whether Pettersson is carrying some sort of injury, perhaps to his back or his wrist. But he moved to quash that speculation.
“He’s just a little sick,” he said.
Pettersson, for his part, said he’s feeling fine.
The misdirection theory makes no sense though because if Tocchet was lying to protect Pettersson physically he wouldn't go and call him out in the same breath.Do you know why?
Because thats how you put a bullseye on an already injured player.
Injury info about Petey only helps his opponents and fans who can't accept the reality that is Petey and definitely Hronek.
Thank you Dr. BenningHurtsMySoul for your valuable insight.
The arguments that Pettersson's play is a result of an injury have always been dubious for a myriad of reasons (this is the second similar stretch of bad play and during the first stretch Pettersson and the team consistently denied any injury), this stretch has been going on for a few months but yet he hasn't sat one game while others have, the team and Pettersson have continually denied it and his former coach who coached him through the last stretch has publicly stated that he thinks its a confidence issue, and rather tellingly, didn't reference any injury, etc.).It’s obvious Tocchet is trying to motivate Pettersson to compete harder. This doesn’t seem to be a case of him trying to convince him to play harder through an injury. That’s silly.
Bad Pettersson, per your definition, still finished 19th in overall scoring. He's been effective with his mind, while you like players that compete. It's a bias.
These things aren't mutually exclusive, which is true, but when one shows predominantly more than the other, you like it or dislike it.
Teams are often super-duper crystal clear about players not being injured and then once playoffs end they in fact were. I'm not saying that is the case with Pettersson at all but what the team says doesn't mean much. It's also pretty clear from the presser today that he is sick right now. Does that excuse the last 4 months. Likely not but it might just be reason for recent issues.
He finished 19th in scoring based on this first half where although his compete wasn't amazing it was an absolute f*** ton better than this.
In his last 50 games he has 36 points. That's a 59 point/82 GP pace which would put him down around 100th in NHL scoring. Non-competing Pettersson is a non-effective Pettersson.
It's not a 'bias' when compete is what actually wins you games in this league in 2024.
You thought his compete "wasn't amazing" while he produced at a 100+ point pace. Is this confirming that he was relying on his mind more than his compete to produce? Yes, and you didn't like that/were not bullish on that version either. It's bias.
I thought what he did in the first half was astonishing, given what he had to work with.
And things aren’t binary. What happened 4 months ago may not be the same reason for what’s happening now. Reasons for last game may not be applicable to last week. Etc.Yeah, but he's 'maybe had an injury' since like November. I get protecting your players but people have been speculating on this a long time. It seems a bit weak, IMO.
I think you're really undervaluing the impact of confidence in a team sport.Thinking that not liking it when talented players don't compete and badly underachieve as a result is a 'bias' is certainly something.
Pettersson had more to give in the first half and was nowhere near his 22-23 levels of all-around play but you'd never hear me saying he was 'bad' or didn't justify his contract. In the last few months, he's been flat-out bad and it's because his compete level is embarrassing. He looks scared to chase a puck if he knows he might get hit.
No different than what he usually sounds like all season.Wow have you guys seen his interview today?
And things aren’t binary. What happened 4 months ago may not be the same reason for what’s happening now. Reasons for last game may not be applicable to last week. Etc.
Less about what he said than his body language and tonality. His confidence and swagger are completely non-existent and he looks clinically depressed.What did he say?
i mean there are rumors that his wrist is messed up (check reddit) and he will get surgery right after the end of the season. Of course we won't know until our season ends after us lifting the cup.There's really people who believe that Rick Tocchet would go out of his way to lie about Pettersson being injured with extreme emphasis using the strongest words we've ever heard from him, completely unprompted.
Canucks vs. Oilers: Rick Tocchet insists Elias Pettersson isn't injured.
And then, Tocchet would publically call Pettersson, a guy who we just signed to an 8-year-contract, a passenger, knowing that he's injured and it isn't his fault.
Pettersson played all 82 games this season.
Brock Boeser, Filip Hronek and JT Miller skipped the final trip of the season to Winnipeg, because we had already locked up #1 in the division, and they wanted to rest some of their bumps and bruises.
Elias Pettersson did not.
He's not injured. Stop with the cope.
I think you're really undervaluing the impact of confidence in a team sport.
When you're thinking out there instead of reacting you become almost useless and the longer that continues the less you want the puck since you don't really believe you'll do something good with it.
He's slumping terribly, no question. But any 'he doesn't compete' stuff is just xenophobic Don Cherry nonsense.
Petey is a superstar because of his precision, skill, and superlative hockey sense.
When he doesn't trust his reads, he becomes just a guy who isn't the fastest nor the biggest.
He's going to learn how to come out of his slumps more quickly but I would hope that you would learn from your takes on Boeser that stars struggle and it doesn't mean that we need to 86 them or that they don't care or won't improve.
it's interesting that people want to say he is not injured and wants to believe that he suddenly changed his playing style from the last like 5 years to where he is avoiding getting hit as if he is afraid of getting injured.He looks scared to chase a puck if he knows he might get hit.
You are the only one tying his lack of compete to his nationality. Those aren't MS's words.I think you're really undervaluing the impact of confidence in a team sport.
When you're thinking out there instead of reacting you become almost useless and the longer that continues the less you want the puck since you don't really believe you'll do something good with it.
He's slumping terribly, no question. But any 'he doesn't compete' stuff is just xenophobic Don Cherry nonsense.
Petey is a superstar because of his precision, skill, and superlative hockey sense.
When he doesn't trust his reads, he becomes just a guy who isn't the fastest nor the biggest.
He's going to learn how to come out of his slumps more quickly but I would hope that you would learn from your takes on Boeser that stars struggle and it doesn't mean that we need to 86 them or that they don't care or won't improve.
it's interesting that people want to say he is not injured and wants to believe that he suddenly changed his playing style from the last like 5 years to where he is avoiding getting hit as if he is afraid of getting injured.
so under what condition would cause someone to be cautious about injuries? perhaps somebody who is already injured? or you just believe that all of a sudden he just decided that he's going to change his game
You are the only one tying his lack of compete to his nationality. Those aren't MS's words.
conveniently that the last time he played like crap he was also coming off a wrist injury that sideline him for like half a season and who knows how long in the offseason and yeah he look eerily similar to that player but I guess the biggest diff was back then he was creating nothing at all.He's not injured. I don't know how much clearer it can get or how much clearer the team can be about it,
This was also his playing style for all of 2021, and over the last 4 years he's played like this more than we've actually seen the 'engaged' Pettersson - which is only the 2nd half of the 21-22 season and all of 22-23.