Proposal: Pens and Rangers

[Skobel24]

I doubt Rutherford would move Pouliot for Hayes and I doubt NY would consider moving Miller/Kreider for him. I almost wonder if Buchnevich or Kovac is a more realistic target for DP.

No chance the Rangers trade a prospect like Buchnevich for someone like Pouliot.

 

[Dylonus]

If Pouliot is going out, I'd add a small + and want Kreider back.

We don't need Kreider to take out goalies for us. That's what The Phil is for

(Side note - Kreider as a Penguin would make me soooo happy.)

 

[Pavel Buchnevich]

Pouliot hasn't shown he can stick in the NHL. The best I'd offer is McIlrath, Fast, Lindberg or a secondary prospect.

 

[One Winged Angel]

Not so much stuck, but rather is the guy who can not be lost by being sent down. Plus, let's not forget that A few years ago, Schultz was what Vessey is this off season.

I'm not understanding the point you're attempting to make by bringing Schultz and Vesey into the discussion.

 

[mgd525]

I don't really like Hayes much. I really question his hockey sense.

Miller I would do. I don't really think the Rangers would without a good add from the Pens.

Kreider is a pipe dream but would LOVE to have him on the Pens. He would be an amazing fit with either Crosby or Malkin.

 

[Ogelthorpe]

I'm not understanding the point you're attempting to make by bringing Schultz and Vesey into the discussion.

The point is he isn't sitting behind stiffs. Schultz has looked very good since coming to Pittsburgh and he is the main competitor for the spot DP would get.

 

[Shootertooter]

JT Miller is not getting moved. Rangers management covets him and will wean and coddle him in the hope of him becoming a true force in the NHL.

 

[FlipFlopPavelski]

First of all most of the proposals here are garbage, the rangers and penguins would never trade with each other since theyre both in the metro or atlantic division, idk which one. Second, hayes or Miller isnt worth pouliout at all. BY GAWD

 

[Elvis Presley]

Second, hayes or Miller isnt worth pouliout at all. BY GAWD

I'm confused. You mean Miller/Hayes > Pouliot, right?

 

[Toby Flenderson]

I'm confused. You mean Miller/Hayes > Pouliot, right?

I'm also confused. The general consensus on here is that Miller>Pouliot and Pouliot>Hayes

 

[Gardner McKay]

Sorry - I forgot how over-hyped prospects who haven't played NHL games are on HF. My bad.

No, it has nothing to do with that. The arrogant tone really isn't needed either (especially when you are ill informed).

Buchnevich was one of three players named untouchable by Gorton at the start of the off-season. So not only is he not being traded, it sure as hell isn't going to be for a mediocre offer. It would take something absurd to pry Buchnevich out of NY since our GM said himself that Buch isn't going anywhere.

 

[flyersfan018]

Pouliot can't even pass Lovejoy on a depth chart. Doubt he has much value right now.