Peak Brad Marchand vs Daniel Alfredsson

[JD1]

This is a good poll.

Alfie being a generally likable player and Marchand having been suspended 8 or 9 times tilts this to Alfie for me.

I just don't like dirt bag hockey players and regardless of how productive he's been, Marchand is a total dirt bag

 

[FabulousLysell]

Ok but he still had 11 goals and 19 pts in the Cup run, 7 points in The Finals and 3 points in game 7

They absolutely don’t win the cup without him, he was a big part of that team.