If there’s anything I trust the Flames on, it’s developing defensemen. In the Gaudreau era, we fixated for years on patching holes in our D to cover up for the fact that we didn’t have the goaltending required for a playoff run.
Hamilton struggles to stay healthy and has never really been dependable in the playoffs. Hanifin never became that top pairing guy that people expect out of a 5th overall pick and is somehow a minus player on Vegas and pacing 35 points. The wheels fell off on Hamonic immediately upon joining.
The only guy that we got that really moved the needle for us was Tanev and he came for free. I’d also say that we got the best years of his career.
I’m not gonna say that our D pairings are solid right now because they’re not. They’re worse than the group we ran heading into the 2015 playoffs. But help is on the way and Conroy did a fantastic job of restocking those cupboards. I also think that this team has quite a good shot at signing Makar the way that things are going for the Avs right now.
The team needs goals and high end playmaking talent. Invest in a Cozens or in a Kakko and don’t let those opportunities pass you by if the cost doesn’t destroy us.
But I really don’t want to see us bleed assets for Dmen again during a rebuild.
Fair, but at the time, we were in a situation where we needed help and an addition to the top 4 urgently (wasn't our top 4 Gio, Brodie, Russell, Wideman (out) and basically no one else? At the time, Hamilton met both criteria while Chabot was too far out. Hamilton vs Chabot in the long run isn't a huge difference IMO. We had a bunch of bottom pairing options, but I don't recall us to be swimming in top 4 options until Treliving came along. Even then, IIRC the majority of those top 4 guys were acquisitions, not home grown. That may have contributed to Kylington, Brodie's and Valimaki's rapid top 4 downfall, but I don't think it was the sole reason those guys suddenly dropped off.
Treliving and Co just stopped trusting our home grown talent after a period of time. This is something I don't worry about with Conroy and Huska. I think there's reason to pursue a quality top pairing dman so that we can potentially run two top like calibre lines, but I don't think it's guaranteed our guys will develop to top line. I can see justification why Conroy might look into it.
Agreed I don't want them to be wasteful. But I also don't think it makes sense to be against looking into adding a top 4 guy if the situation and cost makes sense.
Pretty sure Fox was just a throw in in that deal no? Like Carolina knew he wouldn’t sign there they just wanted to try and pitch him anyway
Also it hurts even more when you realize NYI drafted Dobson with the first from the Hamonic trade
I think his estimated value at the time was a 2nd (rising up from 3rd). I know
@Tkachuk Norris was saying his value was closer to a 1st, but even after the Canes got him, his value hit 2 seconds due to him only wanting to go to the Rangers, not a first. Honestly speaking, the Rags blinked first if they paid that price to pry Fox out of Carolina.
The Dobson picks hurts twice as much because that Hamonic should have helped to strengthen the team. The entire team imploded thus giving NYI a higher pick than expected. I'm pretty sure the expectation was that pick should have been in the 20s.
He was definitely not a throw in. The Canes really wanted him and believed they could sign him
There was definitely debate whether he was a throw in at the time. While Fox's stock was rising, there was only one team that could get him on the roster, if Fox did the NCAA UFA route, the team holding him wouldn't have much of anything to show for it later on due to the fact he was drafted with a 3rd rounder. I don't even know what compensatory pick a team would get if he did that.
In hindsight, I think it's more obvious that it was a special "throw in". He wasn't a throw in because he was valueless. He was a throw in because there was a risk that the team could end up with basically nothing if he decided he wanted to do things in a way to get himself to the Rangers.
Now, also at the time, IIRC
@Tkachuk Norris argued that who we had on our dcorps might have contributed to Fox not wanting to sign, feeling that his path to the NHL was blocked. This speculation also contributed towards amplifying the scenario that ended with Fox on the Rangers.