Out of Town Round 1 Playoff Thread

cptjeff

Reprehensible User
Sep 18, 2008
21,819
39,284
Washington, DC.
I mean, how much of their cap is devoted to Tavares/Matthews/Marner/Nylander? For someone who the main board and Leafs fans were hella excited for and called "boy wonder" and a genius among others, Dubas ignored the blue-line and backup goaltender situation.
Their roster was ridiculously unbalanced before they got Tavares. Then they went out and got Tavares, somehow finding a way to make it even worse. And apparently he made them commit to not breaking up the existing three.

It's a poorly built team, no matter what Leafs fans tell themselves (and the rest of us, loudly). Of course, the delusion of Leafs fans that somehow this is a good team or that Dubas is anything but a shitty GM is what makes their yearly collapses so damn satisfying. So let's go Habs, the entire hockey world is counting on you!
 

TheReelChuckFletcher

Former TheRillestPaulFenton; Harverd Alum
Jun 30, 2011
10,961
25,009
Raleigh and Chapel Hill, NC
Their roster was ridiculously unbalanced before they got Tavares. Then they went out and got Tavares, somehow finding a way to make it even worse. And apparently he made them commit to not breaking up the existing three.

It's a poorly built team, no matter what Leafs fans tell themselves (and the rest of us, loudly). Of course, the delusion of Leafs fans that somehow this is a good team or that Dubas is anything but a shitty GM is what makes their yearly collapses so damn satisfying. So let's go Habs, the entire hockey world is counting on you!

I can't pick on Dubas too much. He's (IMO) been very good at the draft table, but the fruit of that work won't truly come alive until at least a few years from now. On the contract front, OTOH, he dug his own grave by giving Matthews and Marner those stupid (by RFA standards) contracts.
 

cptjeff

Reprehensible User
Sep 18, 2008
21,819
39,284
Washington, DC.
I can't pick on Dubas too much. He's (IMO) been very good at the draft table, but the fruit of that work won't truly come alive until at least a few years from now. On the contract front, OTOH, he dug his own grave by giving Matthews and Marner those stupid (by RFA standards) contracts.

Drafting success after the first round is much more on the scouting staff than the GM. The GM, OTOH, is the only person with any control over the overall construction and balance of the roster, and that's where the Leafs' problems are. They don't lack talent. The roster is fundamentally misaligned with what it takes to actually have playoff success in the NHL. That is on Dubas and nobody else. The contracts are bad, but they're not really the problem. The problem is that they have focused exclusively on high end forward talent while sacrificing defensive talent and depth. That is a choice they, and more specifically Kyle Dubas, made.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad