Proposal: Ottawa / Detroit

[Yakupov64]

Ottawa receives: Moritz Seider

Detroit receives: Brady Tkachuk and Jakob Chychrun

Click to read more...

 

[WingsToPick4th]

Ottawa receives: Moritz Seider

Detroit receives: Brady Tkachuk and Jakob Chychrun

tough call honestly, really good value, Sens say no, wings consider it but hate brady lol

 

[norrisnick]

Pass. Someone has to actually defend.

 

[lanceuppercut75]

Wings should say no. If Tkachuk was a 1C and not a 1W, then perhaps, at least, in theory. 1st line wingers are never as important as 1st line centers or top pair D. I was a Leafs fan during the Kessel years. I had to learn the hard way. Detroit could make a counter-offer involving Stutzle, but based on their roster, they need their 1D more than they need to add a 1C.

 

[bringbacktheskate604]

Wings should say no. If Tkachuk was a 1C and not a 1W, then perhaps, at least, in theory. 1st line wingers are never as important as 1st line centers or top pair D. I was a Leafs fan during the Kessel years. I had to learn the hard way. Detroit could make a counter-offer involving Stutzle, but based on their roster, they need their 1D more than they need to add a 1C.

Mo is likely a 40-50 point guy with an edge. Valuable for sure but Brady is a unicorn with DNA built for the playoffs, he's a guy with all his intangibles, gives him value above a winger imo. Add in Chychrun as well makes the wings the winner imo.

 

[lanceuppercut75]

Mo is likely a 40-50 point guy with an edge. Valuable for sure but Brady is a unicorn with DNA built for the playoffs, he's a guy with all his intangibles, gives him value above a winger imo. Add in Chychrun as well makes the wings the winner imo.

Seider is a 1D, regardless of how many points he puts up. Can't see a team trading a 1D for a unicorn winger. MAYBE if the team has two 1D and trades one of them. Still very questionable IMO and probably still doesn't happen.

 

[Pavels Dog]

Why would Ottawa trade Tkachuk and why would Detroit trade Seider?

 

[bringbacktheskate604]

Seider is a 1D, regardless of how many points he puts up. Can't see a team trading a 1D for a unicorn winger. MAYBE if the team has two 1D and trades one of them. Still very questionable IMO and probably still doesn't happen.

For sure he's a #1D and a good one but I do think he got over hyped offensively after his rookie season.
Wingers even the best aren't as valuable but adding Chychrun puts it over just based on Value.
But I guess unless there's a feeling Edvinson can be a #1, it wouldn't make sense.

 

[TBF1972]

Mo is likely a 40-50 point guy with an edge. Valuable for sure but Brady is a unicorn with DNA built for the playoffs, he's a guy with all his intangibles, gives him value above a winger imo. Add in Chychrun as well makes the wings the winner imo.

can we first see him once in a playoff game before rushing to judgment?

 

[HisNoodliness]

Ottawa receives: Moritz Seider

Detroit receives: Brady Tkachuk and Jakob Chychrun

Great value, probably one of the only ways I even think about moving Seider... But I'll pass. Tkachuk is a special player and Chychrun would really help ease the blow of losing Seider. Seider is too valuable to the Wings though. We can't trade him.

 

[Gaud]

I think the value is enough for the Wings to think about it, but they say no. Oddly, I think id prefer Tkachuk and Chychrun than Seider, so it must be a good deal.

 

[GCK]

Sens say no rather quickly

 

[The Devilish Buffoon]

Not happening but definitely the best Brady proposal I’ve seen on here

 

[Nac Mac Feegle]

I would have a really hard time offering Brady 1-for-1. Adding another player into the mix really tips the scales for Detroit here.

 

[Akrapovince]

Wings would be much better off pursuing a free agent than to part ways with their Chris Pronger-lite.

We hear it all the time, defensemen and centres are more highly regarded than wingers. Now add in the fact that Seider is a right shot, it skews it even more.

I think there’s a lot better options for Wings to fill out their offense than this.

 

[nbwingsfan]

tough call honestly, really good value, Sens say no, wings consider it but hate brady lol

Wings absolutely do not consider it.

Chychrun as our #1D and we just become Ottawa 2.0 (a horrible defensive team with horrible goaltending)

 

[OmniSens]

Easy no for Ottawa. Brady is irreplaceable.

 

[Golden_Jet]

Wings should say no. If Tkachuk was a 1C and not a 1W, then perhaps, at least, in theory. 1st line wingers are never as important as 1st line centers or top pair D. I was a Leafs fan during the Kessel years. I had to learn the hard way. Detroit could make a counter-offer involving Stutzle, but based on their roster, they need their 1D more than they need to add a 1C.

Brady did take 380 faceoffs,
But Senators would easily pass on the proposal.

 

[Hockey Know it all]

Honestly, not a bad proposal, but I wouldn’t even think of trading Seider unless it’s for a top 10 center and someone who is under 25.

Yzerman definitely wouldn’t consider this until he knows what Edvinsson and ASP become. So this trade probably wouldn’t even come to fruition for another 2-3 years.

 

[GIN ANTONIC]

Neutral fan saying Detroit takes this and runs. Seider is great but you can’t turn down that kind of value for him

 

[Yakupov64]

To all the Detroit fans who want a center, nothing stopping you from talking to stl and getting Thomas involved with tkachuk as part of a three team trade. But I’m not doing the framework for that whole deal

 

[TGWL]

To all the Detroit fans who want a center, nothing stopping you from talking to stl and getting Thomas involved with tkachuk as part of a three team trade. But I’m not doing the framework for that whole deal

And nothing is stopping them from cutting out Ottawa completely.

 

[branch]

Wow

 

[KevinRedkey]

I'd rather just keep Brady, sign Tanev/Roy/Pesce, and get picks for Chychrun.

I assume Detroit would also rather keep their best Dman.

 

[Altimus]

This is one of them hand grenade proposals designed to piss both sides off, right.