OOT Scoreboard 2023-24 playoffs

  • Work is still on-going to rebuild the site styling and features. Please report any issues you may experience so we can look into it. Click Here for Updates
Status
Not open for further replies.
It’s hard to fault Toronto for picking Matthews and Marner and Nylander. All have performed well but somehow they have all contributed in various ways to the team not being cohesive in my view. Do they all demand tip top dollar and maybe come across as a bit selfish in other organizations? Hard to say. Was the mistake adding Tavares? They had some depth players this season but could not find a way to get over the playoff hurdle once again. If you move Marner and Tavares what next? You probably want to keep Nylander and Matthews so how do you get them appropriate teammates? Adding via UFA will probably cause similar problems. It’s tricky. They can’t just throw money at the problem since that is kind of sort of what got them to this point.
Even when winning a series last year (against Tampa was it?) I don't believe I've seen this Leafs play better team hockey than in the past 3 games. Their physical play, defensive effort and structure, their commitment to shutting down the center of the ice and not allowing the Bruins any chances was quite unlike anything the Leafs have done in recent memory. The team made huge progress this season and was probably man for man better than Boston. Swayman stole that game last night.

Oddly they lost more because they didn't score than because they didn't defend. Again quite unlike Leafs' teams past.

Keith in my mind deserves a fair amount of credit. They were determined and physical. Focused. They showed a good stock of heavy, young and reasonably fast players too in this series. That big dude (Kise, Kiese? hmm) has a good future.

It's unfortunate that they may now make a whole lot of radical changes based on losing a single game. This series was very different from the pattern that's developed over the past decade or more. This club was quite different. It was for me a much more appealing team to watch and I feel badly that they lost last night, when they had so many looks at Swayman especially in the 2d period and simply couldn't finish, and then there's one quick breakdown in OT.

Samsonov could have read that game winner better and gotten to the puck first with a poke check. A leaf defender didn't turn and go with Pasta. And that was all she wrote.

If I'm a rational Toronto GM I hesitate to break up this team. Kept more or less together I think they can be a winner and I haven't felt that way about them any time in the recent past.
 
The real weakness of the Leafs IMO is their defense. After Reilly, is there a single dman on that team you'd want in your top-4 in the playoffs? Every team going to the second round has multiple guys who would be #1 defenders on bad teams. The Leafs have Reilly (miscast as #1 IMO) and then like 7 Joel Edmundsons.

Tavares isn't worth the money, but if I'm Treliving/Shanny, I run it back one more year with a different coach and another useful defenseman or two and see what happens.
 
I gotta wonder if we see Shanahan just abruptly fired out of nowhere.

I think he's been there 10 years or has it been 11?

He's had 4 GM's I think? He inherited the first. Probably about 3 or 4 head coaches now? Just one single playoff series win.

He's one of the more longer tenured GM's/POHO's in the league now.

The list of the heads of team front office members around the league that have been with their current team longer than him as the head of their front office isn't at all long.

Armstrong in St. Louis, Chevy in Winnipeg come to mind.

After Sather, Poile and Doug Wilson have all been out of power the last several years there aren't any others. Maybe you can consider Mario Lemieux in Pittsburgh? I'm not sure I should include guys with ownership stakes though.

JD has been in Columbus a really long time if you forget about the two year affair that he had with the Rangers in between.
 
At least Carolina won't roll over and die like the caps
I don't think the Caps rolled over and died. I think they just sucked.

It's like trying to push a crappy old car across the country for a big road trip.

A crappy old car that's not even reliable enough to go to your local grocery store and you're walking there half the time because the car is such a decrepit roach.

Better yet - The Caps were already rolled over and dead before that series started. They rolled over and died several years ago.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad