piqued
nos merentur hoc
- Nov 22, 2006
- 33,062
- 4,102
Ongoing Powerplay Discussion
- Thread starter piqued
- Start date
Troy McClure
Should’ve drafted Makar
piqued
nos merentur hoc
- Nov 22, 2006
- 33,062
- 4,102
Ah, it's my favorite thread.
Still waiting on putting Duchene on the top unit. And Harley to top unit. Any day now.
It won't show as a PP goal, but the lone goal yesterday was from.... you guessed it... Harley getting the point shot through the first layer of PKer.
Also we could talk about how we have possibly the deepest forward group in our salary cap era yet somehow have arguably 3 forwards taking shifts on the powerplay who shouldn't be there at all (Dadonov, Marchment, Benn)
The problem goes beyond Xs and Os -- it's a fundamental misunderstanding of how to build units in the first place, coupled with a slavish dedication to giving veterans and players with seniority all of the looks.
Still waiting on putting Duchene on the top unit. And Harley to top unit. Any day now.
It won't show as a PP goal, but the lone goal yesterday was from.... you guessed it... Harley getting the point shot through the first layer of PKer.
Also we could talk about how we have possibly the deepest forward group in our salary cap era yet somehow have arguably 3 forwards taking shifts on the powerplay who shouldn't be there at all (Dadonov, Marchment, Benn)
The problem goes beyond Xs and Os -- it's a fundamental misunderstanding of how to build units in the first place, coupled with a slavish dedication to giving veterans and players with seniority all of the looks.
Kcb12345
Registered User
- Jun 6, 2017
- 31,033
- 24,647
It's especially frustrating considering zone entries really haven't been the main issue this year. We have guys who can enter the zone now, but once they're inside they look like they have no plan or strategy whatsoever
piqued
nos merentur hoc
- Nov 22, 2006
- 33,062
- 4,102
The kids are basically free zone entries because they can actually control the puck.
The reason I call out the group of Dadonov/Marchment/Benn is because they bleed possession when they're already set up in the zone and the PKers know it and who to target with pressure. Benn at least counteracts that by winning faceoffs.
The reason I call out the group of Dadonov/Marchment/Benn is because they bleed possession when they're already set up in the zone and the PKers know it and who to target with pressure. Benn at least counteracts that by winning faceoffs.
piqued
nos merentur hoc
- Nov 22, 2006
- 33,062
- 4,102
Now down to 16% and 25th in the league.
I think my bigger problem beyond personnel and tactics is the level of importance the Stars seem place on the powerplay. It's treated as a "nice to have" component of their overall game rather than an absolute essential, which it should be. Oh golly gee we'll get it figured out with a few more practices.
The org seems to think they can 5-on-5 their way to a Cup when the cold hard reality of the modern game is that results are decided on special teams and even strength becomes a glorified time-kill during the playoffs in between powerplays.
The most important things your team can do:
1) score on the PP
2) draw penalties
3) kill penalties
........
4) roll 4 lines at even strength <---- we are here
I think my bigger problem beyond personnel and tactics is the level of importance the Stars seem place on the powerplay. It's treated as a "nice to have" component of their overall game rather than an absolute essential, which it should be. Oh golly gee we'll get it figured out with a few more practices.
The org seems to think they can 5-on-5 their way to a Cup when the cold hard reality of the modern game is that results are decided on special teams and even strength becomes a glorified time-kill during the playoffs in between powerplays.
The most important things your team can do:
1) score on the PP
2) draw penalties
3) kill penalties
........
4) roll 4 lines at even strength <---- we are here
Troy McClure
Should’ve drafted Makar
It's not like the PP has been bad or anything. During the entire time DeBoer has been coach, the Stars have the 6th best regular season PP and 5th best playoff PP. The PP has been good in every playoff series but the one against the Oilers in the conference finals where they shockingly scored zero PP goals. The other five series saw PP percentages ranging from 23.5% to 37.%.
But there is something about the way the PP tries to generate scoring chances when in a slump. My view is Pavelski's deflection magic has created a problem for the team because they so often default to lobbing wristers from the point as their primary means of PP attack all because they have had a lot of great goals come from Pavelski, Benn, Hintz, and Johnston deflecting pucks. The top guys not scoring seems to have sapped a lot of their confidence to generate the types of down low scoring chances that are most effective and are defaulting to a perimeter game with lame shots form distance.
piqued
nos merentur hoc
- Nov 22, 2006
- 33,062
- 4,102
They're definitely still running the Pavelski Power Play just without the person who made it work (and one of the best to ever do it).
Harley and Heiskanen should be primarily distributors and pressure release valves.
Benn and Marchment's presence are also a reaction to trying to recreate what Pavelski brought. Put big body in front to tip pucks. But unlike Pavelski they're turnover machines/possession blackholes the rest of the time.
They need to deploy players who can operate down low and on the wall like Bourque and yes, the horror, Lundkvist.
Harley and Heiskanen should be primarily distributors and pressure release valves.
Benn and Marchment's presence are also a reaction to trying to recreate what Pavelski brought. Put big body in front to tip pucks. But unlike Pavelski they're turnover machines/possession blackholes the rest of the time.
They need to deploy players who can operate down low and on the wall like Bourque and yes, the horror, Lundkvist.
Azzuri
Registered User
- Feb 6, 2017
- 704
- 790
I remember watching Pete D's Sharks years ago and thinking the same thing about their PP then. If the point shot doesn't work then they were very ineffective. He's always been a one trick pony relying on point/deflections in this regard.
starsfan86
Registered User
- Sep 27, 2006
- 4,880
- 3,604
Troy McClure
Should’ve drafted Makar
He will never be fired as long as DeBoer is the coach.
BrettHullsToe
'99*
Best time to fire DeBoer was last spring before he coached this team out of a Cup win with his terrible handling of the defense (along with Spott's awful PP). Berube's Leafs are playing better than they are, he definitely would have got us at least to the Final.
Second best time to fire DeBoer is yesterday, third best time is right now. Sadly, Nill isn't the kind of GM to pull the trigger.
Kcb12345
Registered User
- Jun 6, 2017
- 31,033
- 24,647
Give me a PP unit with Bourque please
Won't happen without some injuries it seems no matter what at this point
Won't happen without some injuries it seems no matter what at this point
piqued
nos merentur hoc
- Nov 22, 2006
- 33,062
- 4,102
Stars are down to 30th in Net PP% which factors in shorthanded goals allowed.
Down there with Boston, St Louis, and NYI
Down there with Boston, St Louis, and NYI
Frozen Failure
They got business in my hockey, and I hate it.
Well that's embarrassing. That should be some indication that it's time to move on from DeBoer, like every team out there has done.
Smelling Salt
Busey is life
Not sure Bork is the answer. Dude looks like Nic Petan 2.0 to me
Troy McClure
Should’ve drafted Makar
You can't really think DeBoer's coaching cost the Stars a Cup, can you? DeBoer didn't cause Pavelski to lose his mojo or Tanev to get hurt.
BrettHullsToe
'99*
Sure I can, Vegas couldn't get a Cup until they fired him, then they immediately got one.
He's a good regular season coach who can't make the necessary adjustments once they meet a similarly skilled opponent that has figured out how to shut them down. Spott's inability to adjust the PP once it stops scoring is just a symptom of a bigger problem of overall coaching inflexibility. It's "trust the system", and "I believe in our players" type thinking which is just code for "I don't know how to quickly adjust to new situations".
LT
Global Moderator
- Jul 23, 2010
- 42,481
- 14,158
I really wonder how much DeBoer tying himself to Spott has hurt him. This is a common theme for all of his teams, the PP just gradually gets worse and worse throughout their tenure.
Smelling Salt
Busey is life
I don't have much of an issue with PDB yet...he didn't sign Dumba. Probably f***ing hates Dumba tbh. He kinda looks like maybe he is figuring out the lines weren't working.
But Spott is inexcusable. Not only does he look clueless, he IS clueless.
It could also be an issue of Miro just not being a PP quarterback. And while I'm not crazy about Miro on the PP usually, the rest of the players out there are not doing him any favours.
But Spott is inexcusable. Not only does he look clueless, he IS clueless.
It could also be an issue of Miro just not being a PP quarterback. And while I'm not crazy about Miro on the PP usually, the rest of the players out there are not doing him any favours.
Accepted wisdom across the league is that you give the PP chances to your best/veteran players. When the vets aren't producing, do you fire the PP coach or swap out the vets?
piqued
nos merentur hoc
- Nov 22, 2006
- 33,062
- 4,102
David had a thorough breakdown today of the Carolina game PP with compilation clips
open.substack.com
I still don't know how that puck didn't get cut off by Oettinger unless he forgot to bring his hockey stick with him back there, even then...
Tales From The Clipped: A measured take on Dallas' power play, and a mixtape on what went wrong versus Carolina
Let's explore this one.
open.substack.com
I still don't know how that puck didn't get cut off by Oettinger unless he forgot to bring his hockey stick with him back there, even then...
Troy McClure
Should’ve drafted Makar
I think this coaching staff puts too much value on practice. They've used that as an excuse a few times about why the PP personnel doesn't change.
