Proposal: NYR- WPG

[rangerstu]

N.Y. RANGERS - Mark Scheifele
Winnepeg - Kappo Kakko , Alexis Lafreniere, Matthew Robinson, Nils Lundkvist, plus 2022 1st round pick. This allows Winnepeg to resign both Dubois and Copp, while stocking up on some talented wingers. The Rangers then could trade Strome and Zac Jones to Arizona for Lawson Crouse, at least I would.

Click to read more...

 

[Mal Reynolds]

Can't see Rangers fans liking this one bit

 

[howkie]

Pretty sure Rangers screams no, and well, not sure we need more wingers to Jets =D

 

[NjdevilfanJim]

Pretty sure Rangers screams no, and well, not sure we need more wingers to Jets =D

Scheifele is a great player on a very good contract but there is no way Rangers do this trade....

 

[Overrateprospects]

N.Y. RANGERS - Mark Scheifele
Winnepeg - Kappo Kakko , Alexis Lafreniere, Matthew Robinson, Nils Lundkvist, plus 2022 1st round pick. This allows Winnepeg to resign both Dubois and Copp, while stocking up on some talented wingers. The Rangers then could trade Strome and Zac Jones to Arizona for Lawson Crouse, at least I would.

Good lord is this bad for Rangers. Winnipeg if they are rebuilding take this to the bank laughing. This is hockey’s version of Herschel Walker trade.

 

[One Winged Angel]

No thanks.

Scheifele is a great player, but the Rangers can’t afford to do that trade without cap going back the other way and they can’t afford to give young ELC talents on the wing, when they lack depth on the right side.

Too much going the other way and it doesn’t make sense.

 

[The Crypto Guy]

N.Y. RANGERS - Mark Scheifele
Winnepeg - Kappo Kakko , Alexis Lafreniere, Matthew Robinson, Nils Lundkvist, plus 2022 1st round pick. This allows Winnepeg to resign both Dubois and Copp, while stocking up on some talented wingers. The Rangers then could trade Strome and Zac Jones to Arizona for Lawson Crouse, at least I would.

This definitely wins the award for the worst proposal i've ever read, and that is saying a lot.

Best part is, this guy apparently made his account in 2013, and THIS was the glorious first post he decided to make. Sure made it a doozy!

 

[PacificOceanPotion]

Did this proposal come from an alternate universe somehow?

 

[Ledge And Dairy]

Scheifele is a great hockey player but Lafreniere 1 for 1 is way closer to fair than this

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

This would basically be like Detroit giving up Larkin+Hronek+Seider+Raymond+Detroit 2022 1st round pick for Mark Scheifele. I mean he's good but he's not Connor McDavid good.

 

[Heldig]

Obviously the Jets would take that deal and run.

 

[Crazy8oooo]

OP is a Rangers fan?? That's a lot of value going to the Jets.

 

[FoxyClean]

OP - Account created 2013, no posts, IP originating from Manitoba, username "rangerstu".

This is one of the weirdest things I've ever seen.

Did you spend the last 9 years preparing this lopsided proposal?

 

[Irie]

OP - Account created 2013, no posts, IP originating from Manitoba, username "rangerstu".

This is one of the weirdest things I've ever seen.

Did you spend the last 9 years preparing this lopsided proposal?

This has got to be Hockeys Future's longest planned troll job.

With 8+ years of preparation, I kinda expected more....

 

[DudeWhereIsMakar]

What shocked me is that this came from a Rangers fan.

But as a Jets fan I'd do this.

 

[Anthony5967]

I’m going to be sick. The best is them also trading Strome and a slick, mobile defender in Jones that hasn’t even been given a ton of runway yet for Lawson frigging Crouse? I don’t even know what to say

 

[Vitto79]

I was expecting to see a Copp or Stastny proposal lol

 

[Digable5]

This has got to be Hockeys Future's longest planned troll job.

With 8+ years of preparation, I kinda expected more....

Ok. My theory is he’s as Jets fan that joined maybe 10 years ago. After posting for a couple years , he decides to make a username for all teams in order to post lopsided Jets trades as the other team’s fan so he doesn’t look like a homer. This is just his first proposal using the Rangers

 

[Irie]

Ok. My theory is he’s as Jets fan that joined maybe 10 years ago. After posting for a couple years , he decides to make a username for all teams in order to post lopsided Jets trades as the other team’s fan so he doesn’t look like a homer. This is just his first proposal using the Rangers

Solid theory

 

[McJedi]

N.Y. RANGERS - Mark Scheifele
Winnepeg - Kappo Kakko , Alexis Lafreniere, Matthew Robinson, Nils Lundkvist, plus 2022 1st round pick. This allows Winnepeg to resign both Dubois and Copp, while stocking up on some talented wingers. The Rangers then could trade Strome and Zac Jones to Arizona for Lawson Crouse, at least I would.

Jets add Kyle Conner and Perfetti. Then you’re probably there.

 

[GAGLine]

What shocked me is that this came from a Rangers fan.

But as a Jets fan I'd do this.

I don't think we can fairly draw that conclusion based simply on the username. There are too many other red flags that suggest otherwise.

 

[Superlative Soup]

OP - Account created 2013, no posts, IP originating from Manitoba, username "rangerstu".

This is one of the weirdest things I've ever seen.

Did you spend the last 9 years preparing this lopsided proposal?

Stu playing the long game

 

[Pure Slaughter Value]

Scheifele is a great hockey player but Lafreniere 1 for 1 is way closer to fair than this

This is just as bad as the OP. Schiefle is now and probably will be for a couple of years a superior player to Laf that plays a position of more importance. Schiefele is having an off year and is still going to get 70 points or so. Lafreniere is buried on the depth chart between two all-star LW's that aren't going anywhere for at least three years.

If Scheifele was being traded for Laf there would be significant piece(s) added by the Rangers. I realize Laf is a young man and this board craves that but being cost-controlled is only factor, performance is another. Even if Laf becomes a 25-25 by the end of the ELC it doesn't offset what Scheifele adds to the Rangers during the same time period, especially as Zibajenad, Panarin, Trouba and Kreider enter their 30's and a Cup window.

 

[Ledge And Dairy]

This is just as bad as the OP. Schiefle is now and probably will be for a couple of years a superior player to Laf that plays a position of more importance. Schiefele is having an off year and is still going to get 70 points or so. Lafreniere is buried on the depth chart between two all-star LW's that aren't going anywhere for at least three years.

If Scheifele was being traded for Laf there would be significant piece(s) added by the Rangers. I realize Laf is a young man and this board craves that but being cost-controlled is only factor, performance is another. Even if Laf becomes a 25-25 by the end of the ELC it doesn't offset what Scheifele adds to the Rangers during the same time period, especially as Zibajenad, Panarin, Trouba and Kreider enter their 30's and a Cup window.

Disagree, Lafreniere still has immense potential and the concept of a 1 for 1 would be based off the Nieuwendyk for Iginla trade. Any add from the rangers would pretty minor or conditional

 

[rangersfansince08]

Ok. My theory is he’s as Jets fan that joined maybe 10 years ago. After posting for a couple years , he decides to make a username for all teams in order to post lopsided Jets trades as the other team’s fan so he doesn’t look like a homer. This is just his first proposal using the Rangers

That's pretty pathetic if true.