Proposal: NYR-VAN-BUF: Practically Impossible Trade.

[biturbo19]

Something in another thread got me thinking about it...and i'd be curious to hear reactions on various sides. Even though there are fundamental roadblocks (NMC) that keep this from being an "actual trade". I'm curious about the "value" or how it would be balanced.


To NYR: Brock Boeser, Travis Hamonic (if necessary).

To VAN: Jacob Trouba.

To BUF: Vitaliy Kravstov, Tyler Myers.







Obviously Trouba's NMC scuttles anything like this, regardless of any value tweaking...but i'm still curious how it'd be received in theory.

Click to read more...

 

[Old Navy Goat]

Something in another thread got me thinking about it...and i'd be curious to hear reactions on various sides. Even though there are fundamental roadblocks (NMC) that keep this from being an "actual trade". I'm curious about the "value" or how it would be balanced.


To NYR: Brock Boeser, Travis Hamonic (if necessary).

To VAN: Jacob Trouba.

To BUF: Vitaliy Kravstov, Tyler Myers.







Obviously Trouba's NMC scuttles anything like this, regardless of any value tweaking...but i'm still curious how it'd be received in theory.

Well it's imbalanced as Buffalo isn't sending out anything

 

[Trojans86]

This is a new low for hf boards

 

[HolyGhost]

Something in another thread got me thinking about it...and i'd be curious to hear reactions on various sides. Even though there are fundamental roadblocks (NMC) that keep this from being an "actual trade". I'm curious about the "value" or how it would be balanced.


To NYR: Brock Boeser, Travis Hamonic (if necessary).

To VAN: Jacob Trouba.

To BUF: Vitaliy Kravstov, Tyler Myers.







Obviously Trouba's NMC scuttles anything like this, regardless of any value tweaking...but i'm still curious how it'd be received in theory.

Trouba wanted out of Canada in the worse way

 

[Shark Finn]

What's Buffalo's role here?

 

[Jumptheshark]

What's Buffalo's role here?

Sal dumps

 

[TBF1972]

Well it's imbalanced as Buffalo isn't sending out anything

myers @3x6m has negative trade value. kravtsov is the compensation for swallowing the contract and i am not sure it's enough.

 

[The Crypto Guy]

We aren't trading Trouba at this point. He's been great for us this season and helps give us 2 very solid defensive pairings.

 

[SingnBluesOnBroadway]

Don’t see the Rangers being in a hurry to move Trouba.

 

[HolyGhost]

Something in another thread got me thinking about it...and i'd be curious to hear reactions on various sides. Even though there are fundamental roadblocks (NMC) that keep this from being an "actual trade". I'm curious about the "value" or how it would be balanced.


To NYR: Brock Boeser, Travis Hamonic (if necessary).

To VAN: Jacob Trouba.

To BUF: Vitaliy Kravstov, Tyler Myers.







Obviously Trouba's NMC scuttles anything like this, regardless of any value tweaking...but i'm still curious how it'd be received in theory.

who does Buffalo give up? I think you are missing a step there or explanation on jus why Buffalo is involved. Both Rangers and Vancouver giving players to Buffalo just because? and one player Buffalo will not want

 

[member 334057]

The Rangers are playing pretty well with their current line-up. If they were to trade Trouba it would more likely be during the offseason when they have time to adjust the roster to fill the hole, but from what I can tell of their cap situation there really is no need to. If they can get Strome to stay for a reasonable amount, Gauthier and Kakko haven't really earned huge increases so far this season so they should be fine cap wise. Ultimately I think they are probably better with Trouba than without.

 

[HFBS]

 

[NYVanfan]

you spelled Lundkvist wrong

Canucks already have one $8M Dman under contract for years into his 30s, no thanks
I wouldnt do this if we took Boeser out
Trouba is undeniably better than Myers or Hamonic, but both older-guys contracts will end much sooner, that's pivotal

If Benning did anything at this moment to bring in more guys older than mid-20s on long term contracts they'd erect a gallows outside GM Place (with apologies to Mike Pence)

 

[MarkusKetterer]

The Rangers are playing pretty well with their current line-up. If they were to trade Trouba it would more likely be during the offseason when they have time to adjust the roster to fill the hole, but from what I can tell of their cap situation there really is no need to. If they can get Strome to stay for a reasonable amount, Laf and Kakko haven't really earned huge increases so far this season so they should be fine cap wise. Ultimately I think they are probably better with Trouba than without.

Laf is only on year two of his contract, so he can’t get a raise anyway.

 

[Glen Sathers Cigar]

you spelled Lunqkvist wrong

Canucks already have one $8M Dman under contract for years into his 30s, no thanks
I wouldnt do this if we took Boeser out
Trouba is undeniably better than Myers or Hamonic, but both older-guys contracts will end much sooner, that's pivotal

If Benning did anything at this moment to bring in more guys older than mid-20s on long term contracts they'd erect a gallows outside GM Place (with apologies to Mike Pence)

So did you. It's Lundkvist.

This trade is hilarious with Buffalo not giving anything up at all and getting two pieces. Trouba isn't getting traded, he's the Rangers' second best defenseman and has been awesome this season (and last season). He had a rough first year in NY as he adjusted so everyone wrote him off as a dud but that couldn't be further from the truth now. He's a big overpaid but on the ice he's been very good and he's very important to the Rangers.

 

[member 334057]

Laf is only on year two of his contract, so he can’t get a raise anyway.

Yea brain fart it was Gauthier and Kakko.

 

[Bacon Artemi Bravo]

If you asked Ranger fans before the season, they would be on board. At this point, Trouba has proven that he is too important to move at this point in time. I think he's just more impactful than Boeser would end up being, even if the NYR do need RW's.

 

[NYVanfan]

So did you. It's Lundkvist.

This trade is hilarious with Buffalo not giving anything up at all and getting two pieces. Trouba isn't getting traded, he's the Rangers' second best defenseman and has been awesome this season (and last season). He had a rough first year in NY as he adjusted so everyone wrote him off as a dud but that couldn't be further from the truth now. He's a big overpaid but on the ice he's been very good and he's very important to the Rangers.

haha i knew i would do that
doh

 

[Djp]

Buffalo isn’t retaining pass thry salary nor taking cap dumps

 

[LetsGoBuffalo1126]

I don't think Buffalo does this as they made a concerted effort to lower their cap number for now and the future. They wouldn't even retain on the Eichel deal to sweeten it. Cap flexibility is important to them, and taking on heavy contracts seems to fly in the face on that theory.

 

[tsujimoto74]

Well it's imbalanced as Buffalo isn't sending out anything

I think Buffalo is getting Kravstov for taking Myers.
The bigger atrocity here is Trouba for Boeser. VAN's GM would wind up dead or hospitalized before you could get him drunk enough to agree to that.

 

[Mogo]

Is Boaser that bad these days he's considered a salary dump?

 

[belair]

Why are the Rangers paying Buffalo to eat Myers' salary?

 

[Ledge And Dairy]

Why do I keep seeing Trouba to x Canadian team trades?

 

[Nucklehead Supreme]

Something in another thread got me thinking about it...and i'd be curious to hear reactions on various sides. Even though there are fundamental roadblocks (NMC) that keep this from being an "actual trade". I'm curious about the "value" or how it would be balanced.


To NYR: Brock Boeser, Travis Hamonic (if necessary).

To VAN: Jacob Trouba.

To BUF: Vitaliy Kravstov, Tyler Myers.







Obviously Trouba's NMC scuttles anything like this, regardless of any value tweaking...but i'm still curious how it'd be received in theory.

Ohhh man so much wrong with this, Hamonic isn't going back to NY as we all know (except you apparently) he wanted out and doesn't want to go back that far away from family.

We can't afford Trouba his cap hit is too much even if he is the type of dman we need, with him OEL and Hughes that's 3 dmen making 7 million plus, on a team that is already against the cap.

Why would Buffalo want Myers back, and why would Myers want to go back to Buffalo?