Proposal: Nyr-car
- Thread starter bfaust30
- Start date
MMC
Global Moderator
DaveG
Noted Jerk
cmon, no way. Pesce's younger then Jensen and is exempt in the upcoming expansion draft. The other assets coming Carolina's way would have to be ridiculous for us to even consider trading out Pesce for Staal.
Brock Anton
flames #badnwagon
sheriff bart
Where are the white women at
No team in the league is going to tie up an expansion protection spot on MStaal. Give up on the trade ideas.
tarheelhockey
Offside Review Specialist
I don't think we're going down the "he can play with his brother" road any more.
The time to try and trade Marc to Carolina was about 3 years ago.
The time to try and trade Marc to Carolina was about 3 years ago.
So the Canes downgrade to a wildly expensive D who plays the wrong side and pick up Jensen for their trouble? Thanks but no thanks.
Nobody is taking Staal (unless the Rags really make it worthwhile for someone). He's overpaid, declining, and his NMC is going to screw just about any team come expansion.
FoxysExpensiveNYDigs
Boo Nieves Truther
Canes have no reason to do a deal like this. Pesce was very good last year along with their other young defensemen.
Roboturner913
Registered User
- Jul 3, 2012
- 25,853
- 55,526
I don't think Carolina would be opposed to trading Pesce for forward help at some point, but Marc Staal does absolutely nothing to help Carolina right now.
Savant
Registered User
- Oct 3, 2013
- 38,366
- 11,469
Is even Staal+Jensen for Hainsey a no from Carolina?
And how much would NYR have to add to a Staal package to acquire Murphy?
Hanifin, Pesce, and Slavin are exempt, but I guess Carolina will protect Faulk in the expansion draft? That leaves the possibility to protect 2 more defensemen out of Hainsey, Murphy, Tennyson, Lowe, Carrick, Robertson...
And how much would NYR have to add to a Staal package to acquire Murphy?
Hanifin, Pesce, and Slavin are exempt, but I guess Carolina will protect Faulk in the expansion draft? That leaves the possibility to protect 2 more defensemen out of Hainsey, Murphy, Tennyson, Lowe, Carrick, Robertson...
RangerGuru
Registered User
- May 14, 2013
- 1,189
- 6
There is no deal where Staal to Carolina works. Staal is a boat anchor that would only stand to stunt the development of Slavin (currently a top-pairing D) and Hanifin (a future top-pairing D). Add in Haydn Fleury, Trevor Carrick, and Jake Bean and there is no room for Staal. Even at 50% retained and adding Buchnevich, the Canes likely still say no.
PG Canuck
Registered User
- Mar 29, 2010
- 63,606
- 25,637
There is no reason to ever take Staal for any team. He has to be protected becaus of his NMC and that just won't fly with any team around the league, hence the Rangers wanting to move him, or the fans I should say.
You will not get anything close to value for Staal.
You will not get anything close to value for Staal.
Boom Boom Apathy
I am the Professor. Deal with it!
- Sep 6, 2006
- 49,397
- 102,372
You guess the Canes would protect Faulk? Of course they will.
Here's the thing. Canes have to expose at least one defensemen who is signed for 17/18 and has played a certain number of games. Hainsey and Tennyson are ufas at seasons end so they don't count. Hanifin, Slavin and Pesce are exempt. Lowe and Robertson, and likely Carrick won't play enough NHL games. So that leaves one of Faulk or Murphy. So, losing Murphy and gaining Staal (who I think had a NMC) would leave Faulk as the one that has to be exposed, since Staal had a NMC and that isn't happening.
I think Murphy sucks and I also think Staal will have a much better season than most think, but contracts and the expansion draft have to be taken into account.
Boom Boom Apathy
I am the Professor. Deal with it!
- Sep 6, 2006
- 49,397
- 102,372
and it should
terribad OP
x2
I have been pushing for Pesce, but not such a ridiculous offer
stepan and 3 Ranger 3rds
for
Pesce, Murphy, cap dump Bickell and 2 Cane 2nds and return of ranger 2nd
One Winged Angel
You Can't Escape
One Winged Angel
You Can't Escape
Terrible for Carolina. They have zero reason to do this.
OP, was there ANY thought put into why Carolina would do a deal like that? Because I know if the roles were reversed, you sure as hell wouldn't do it.
OP, was there ANY thought put into why Carolina would do a deal like that? Because I know if the roles were reversed, you sure as hell wouldn't do it.
Machinehead
HFNYR MVP
RodTheBawd
Registered User
- Oct 16, 2013
- 5,529
- 8,604
Shootertooter
Registered User
- Feb 20, 2016
- 3,676
- 1,487
you think the other offer is worse than this? Stop trying to sell Step, he is not going anywhere! And in the event that he is moved, it will be for an established stud RHD like Barrie...and I am not thinking that this will happen either.
Gardner McKay
RIP, Jimmy.
No. The OP makes a new Rangers proposal almost every day and it is either us completely ripping one team of or the Rangers completely getting ripped off. Nothing in between.
