Nylander vs Dzingel

[Hugh Mungus]

Who's better?

Nylander: 17-1-2-3p
Dzingel: 45-19-16-35p

Click to read more...

 

[sparxx87]

Let’s add some context:

Player 1 - 26 years old
Career - GP 235 - G 59 - A 58 - Pts 117

Player 2 - 22 years old
Career - GP 202 - G 49 - A 89 - Pts 138

OP is embarrassing. I’d also encourage you to look up the definition of neutral. Negative bias actually means you’re not neutral.

 

[koyvoo]

Geez, I myself am super critical of Nylander but he’s better than Dzingel. This is silly.

 

[WhiskeyYerTheDevils]

Let’s add some context:

Player 1 - 26 years old
Career - GP 235 - G 59 - A 58 - Pts 117

Player 2 - 22 years old
Career - GP 202 - G 49 - A 89 - Pts 138

OP is embarrassing. I’d also encourage you to look up the definition of neutral. Negative bias actually means you’re not neutral.

Not all players develop on the same curve, or even in a linear fashion. Right now, I like Dzingel's game more. If Nylander is eventually able to shake off the rust it'll probably be him but Dzingel's shot and skill always impresses me - reminds me of Hoffman. He's also on pace to destroy Nylander's career high in goals without the benefit of Auston Matthews.

Also - you may think this is a ridiculous comparison, but what you are feeling right now is what I experienced when you and the rest of Toronto were arguing with me that Nylander > Gaudreau at the start of last season:
Willy Nylander vs Gaudreau

 

[arrbez]

Do people think that William Nylander is actually just going to be a 15 point player for the rest of his career...

 

[koyvoo]

Do people think that William Nylander is actually just going to be a 15 point player for the rest of his career...

Imagine saying “if Kopitar picks it up, it’ll probably be him, but for now I have to say that Lindholm is a better C”.

 

[HockeyDBspecialist]

I prefer Dzingel 200ft play thann NYlander. Nylander is sooo soft it's annoying to watch

 

[sparxx87]

Not all players develop on the same curve, or even in a linear fashion. Right now, I like Dzingel's game more. If Nylander is eventually able to shake off the rust it'll probably be him but Dzingel's shot and skill always impresses me - reminds me of Hoffman. He's also on pace to destroy Nylander's career high in goals without the benefit of Auston Matthews.

Also - you may think this is a ridiculous comparison, but what you are feeling right now is what I experienced when you and the rest of Toronto were arguing with me that Nylander > Gaudreau at the start of last season:
Willy Nylander vs Gaudreau

So you’re bitter I disagreed with you a year ago? And your response is to oppose me on this and kill your own credibility?

You’ll notice a poll like this re; a Leaf player is usually full of responses and votes after being open for several hours... This one is an exception. Any idea why?

 

[XXIV97]

Dzingle is better right now but Nylander will be better in the future

 

[Laminator]

I cheer for the Senators and I am a huge Dzingel fan. However Nylander is a much better hockey player. Yes Nylander is having a bad year but he will bounce back next year.

 

[Taluss]

I don’t see how even a Sens fan wouldn’t vote Nyl here. Sure Dzingle is player better rn but doesn’t mean much considering the different situation between the 2

 

[ImpartialNHLfan]

Reads post
Checks profile pic
See's agenda

 

[Morgs]

Lmaooooooooooooooo.

 

[SPF6ty9]

This Sens fans would pack Dzingel's bags and drive him all the way to Toronto for Nylander. Ridiculous question, Nylander is the far superior talent.

 

[Rob Brown]

What a ridiculous poll.

 

[Korpse]

I prefer Dzingel 200ft play

Dzingel and 200ft play should not be used in the same sentence.

 

[NyQuil]

Where's the Sens fan voting for Nylander option?

I'm not changing my opinion on William Nylander until the end of next season.

 

[LeafGrief]

Do Nylander versus Pontus Aberg next.

 

[Spirit of 67]

Who's better?

Nylander: 17-1-2-3p
Dzingel: 45-19-16-35p

Wow. Troll much?

 

[TheDoldrums]

Not all players develop on the same curve, or even in a linear fashion. Right now, I like Dzingel's game more. If Nylander is eventually able to shake off the rust it'll probably be him but Dzingel's shot and skill always impresses me - reminds me of Hoffman. He's also on pace to destroy Nylander's career high in goals without the benefit of Auston Matthews.

Also - you may think this is a ridiculous comparison, but what you are feeling right now is what I experienced when you and the rest of Toronto were arguing with me that Nylander > Gaudreau at the start of last season:
Willy Nylander vs Gaudreau

Not sure if the guy who argued for Fiala over Marner should be on a high horse over old polls.

Marner VS Fiala

I'm sure this take will age just as well.

 

[topshelf15]

Yeah Nylander wins this hands down ,the comparision isnt realy fair to Dzingle here...He is a solid player in his own right,but Nylander is much better

 

[Rodzilla]

Senators fan ; Nylander. Easy

 

[dubey]

Imagine actually thinking Dzingel is better than Nylander

Yikes

 

[flamesforcup]

So you’re bitter I disagreed with you a year ago? And your response is to oppose me on this and kill your own credibility?

You’ll notice a poll like this re; a Leaf player is usually full of responses and votes after being open for several hours... This one is an exception. Any idea why?

Damn you really voted Nylander over Gaudreau? LOL. And like @WhiskeyYourTheDevils said development is not linear. Ive seen the development argument used by Leafs fans to argue Marner>Gaudreau, Rielly>Kieth, Matthews>Mackinnon etc. but its just dumb to expect a player to stay on an upwards curve. I mean Nylander was better than Gaudreau and Kucherov at the same age i guess u would take him over them? Theres more to the game than checking stats and age and automatically expecting it to go up.

 

[WetcoastOrca]

Nylander is the clear choice. He brings good offense and still has upside to grow his game. Needs to work on not getting physically intimidated and on his defensive game but his current production is not indicative of the type of player he is.