Its not controversial to wonder that, but its also dense to ignore that this is the third coach now, third highly respected coach around the league, who has trusted G as an integral part of their D. Not just on the defense, but one of the more trusted defenseman. A different fan-base also seems to like his contribution or are they not entitled to an opinion? Players with better corsi's on that defense like Dotchin and Sustr are widely hated by their fans, so its not like they are happy with the contributions of all defensemen. They only like the play of Hedman, Stralman, Sergachyov and Girardi, a few are also okay with Coburn and Koekkoek.
Matter settled that he's an ECHL player because the shot attempts against column isn't what you'd want it to be?
If you look up "appeal to authority" in the dictionary there's a picture of you.