Proposal: Nico Hischier for Jason Robertson

[Kcb12345]

Man this just makes no sense lol

 

[Satan]

Much needed? With Ritz, Seguin, Johnson and Duchene the last thing they need is a centre. You can just make up a reason for Dallas to do the trade.

They would be trading the better player, creating a hole in their lineup and not addressing a need, rather adding to a surplus.

Ritz is a stale cracker at this point in his career

 

[Boss Man Hughes]

Robertson is the better player. I dont see why Dallas touches this.

Isn't Robertson a bad skater? He could be done much earlier than Hischier.

 

[Baksfamous112]

Isn't Robertson a bad skater? He could be done much earlier than Hischier.

Skating is the first thing to go in a regressing player. Shot & IQ is what stick the longest

 

[Kcb12345]

Isn't Robertson a bad skater? He could be done much earlier than Hischier.

Not sure why that would matter. He doesn't succeed because of his skating so it won't impact him anymore later on either

 

[NVious]

Markstrom
Hughes
Hughes
Hamilton

for

Heiskenanen
Robertson
Oettinger

 

[WhiskeyYerTheDevils]

Markstrom
Hughes
Hughes
Hamilton

for

Heiskenanen
Robertson
Oettinger

Hahaha

 

[Zajacs Bowl Cut]

Markstrom
Hughes
Hughes
Hamilton

for

Heiskenanen
Robertson
Oettinger

you know hockey season is close when you start getting bangers like these on this board

 

[Moist ReadOnly]

Bad for both teams

 

[NVious]

you know hockey season is close when you start getting bangers like these on this board

WHO SAYS NO???????

 

[WhataKnight]

WHO SAYS NO???????

 

[McJedi]

Man this just makes no sense lol

I’d rather have Hischier. He’s the better player.​

​

Fun trade idea​

​

​

 

[My3Sons]

OP is somewhat infamous on the NJ board for posting goofy trade proposals so this is his delusional idea and not to be smeared to all NJ fans. Thanks.

 

[Dr Pepper]

View attachment 907609

I’d rather have Hischier. He’s the better player.​

​

Fun trade idea​

​

​

Looks like we found the one "YES" in a vote that is currently 64 to 1.

 

[TBF1972]

Looks like we found the one "YES" in a vote that is currently 64 to 1.

you can say no or yes regardless which player you think is better.

 

[Dr Pepper]

you can say no or yes regardless which player you think is better.

Uh huh.

And 64 voters, regardless of team allegiance, voted no.

 

[dirtydanglez]

id rather robertson.

 

[Jerzey Devil]

Uh huh.

And 64 voters, regardless of team allegiance, voted no.

As in 63 of them could be Devils fans saying no because we’d rather keep Hischier.

 

[HugeInTheShire]

Uh huh.

And 64 voters, regardless of team allegiance, voted no.

What does voting no mean to you? OP gives absolutely zero context about what we're voting on.
I assumed that because the OP is a Devils fan he was asking. If you were the Devils and Dallas offered Robertson for Hischier, would you accept? Yes or No? So I voted no.

But I wouldn't accept it if I was Dallas either. Both teams trading something they need for something they don't.

 

[lightsout]

No.

Stop.

No.

Stop.

 

[JPT]

What does voting no mean to you? OP gives absolutely zero context about what we're voting on.
I assumed that because the OP is a Devils fan he was asking. If you were the Devils and Dallas offered Robertson for Hischier, would you accept? Yes or No? So I voted no.

But I wouldn't accept it if I was Dallas either. Both teams trading something they need for something they don't.

I voted no and I don't give a shit about either team. That's how bad it is lol

 

[HugeInTheShire]

I voted no and I don't give a shit about either team. That's how bad it is lol

I agree, everyone should vote no, this trade isn't what either team needs.

 

[hamzarocks]

As a player J Robertson > Hischier imo by a bit

NH Is also a need as a strong 2C who takes high end 2nd lines and is expected to outplay/out chance them

Robertson's contract expiring sooner and him getting a larger cpa hit makes value closer

Both teams should say no and keep their guy

This trade is similar to Jack Hughes for Heiskinen. Hughes would be the better player while Heiskinen has less injury risks and has elite playoff play being a boon to make value closer

That would be another trade both teams reject

 

[Boss Man Hughes]

Not sure why that would matter. He doesn't succeed because of his skating so it won't impact him anymore later on either

It will matter in the long run if he is a below average skater. Once they lose a step (like Cheechoo after hernia surgery) they are done because while all other skills are still good they can't keep up or get in scoring position. When Toffoli loses a step he will be pretty much done.

 

[CanadienShark]

As a fan of neither team, I don't like this trade for either team.