The NHL did everything they could to stay in the state for decades.Phoenix is the 10th largest MSA but it is also the 4th fastest growing in the country. The NHL pulling out of this market is a huge mistake for hockey.
Utah is the 50th largest MSA.
At the end of the day, this may have been a win for Utah and certain NHL owners but this is a loss for hockey popularity in the US which is what *should* matter to the NHL. If the NHL wants to grow in an increasingly competitive sports market in the US, it needs to do more to expand popularity of the sport. Otherwise it will continue to lose popularity to football, basketball and soccer.
Just look at management of the MLS compared to the NHL. The MLS is actively looking to cut deals to expand into new locations and bring in big players. They are actually making decisions that benefit not just the league but also soccer in the US. The MLS is going to eat the NHLs lunch unless they start making smarter decisions. To be honest, I don't have much confidence the NHL will figure it out.
If there is truly a NHL sized appetite for hockey in Arizona then the state has 5 years to make it happen. If they can't, then it wasn't meant to be.
There are a lot of cities that would be salivating at the opportunity the NHL has given them.
Of course MLS is going to be more popular in the US than the NHL. Long term it is the NFL that needs to be concerned with the MLS, not the NHL or NBA.
And you know that how?5,999 of them being corporations and scalpers looking to sell them at inflated prices.
Either way, the tickets are sold.