Some great stories in here. I wish I could've gone to the old buildings, from the descriptions I've read it almost sounds like the arenas WERE hockey, just in another form. I've been to a few current arenas (mostly out west).
Rogers Arena a number times, including during the Olympics- its a nice rink, if not a bit average by todays standards. The location is awesome (downtown and the skytrain takes you right up to the door). Every time I'm there (was at a game last week in fact) I think of Crosby's famous OT winner. Would be nice to have a statue of him out there one day.
Rexall Place too many times to count- really an awful arena in NHL context, but full of nostalgia for me. Saw my first game in 99 at the age of 4 and a half and distinctly remember a Mighty Ducks player waiving back to me during warmups. Also attended the well known Stefan-gaffe game in 07. In fact I even saw a game in the press box there! Great memories from a rink that housed maybe the greatest NHL team ever.
HP Pavilion once- went to a playoff game a couple years ago; the atmosphere was unlike anything I've ever experienced. Lived on air force bases as a kid and the noise reminded me of an F-18 soaring off. Sharks won the series in OT, saw the Rolling Stones there the next night.
Staples Center once- same road trip, went to a Kings playoff game. The LA Live district is top notch-- so many entertainment options before and after the game. The whole set up is very LA (and I mean that as a compliment). Awesome arena as well, it feels very wide open and grand. Given the large number of high profile events that go on there (Grammys, Lakers winning a few titles, Kings winning a couple, major concerts, MJ's service, etc), dare I say MSG West? Maybe eventually...
Honda Center once- great road trip, hey? Game 7 Ducks-Red Wings. Great game, but I wasn't digging the atmosphere. Seemed... subdued. Odd. The building isn't bad but you can tell its from the 90's. Very basic and cookie cutter.
Jobing.Com Arena twice- cool barn, I love the district around it. A lot of entertainment options and some great restaurants too. The main issue (probably doesn't need repeating) is the location; way out in the suburbs. Imagine the Canucks playing out in Abbotsford, yikes. Wasn't a problem for me as the trip was planned around the games but that is awful for locals I'd imagine.
BB&T Center twice- pretty nice arena, suffers from the same issue as the Yotes though in the location. Plus there isn't really anything immediately around the rink (there is a gigantic mall about a 10 minute walk away, but the way the arena is just "there" without anything close by kind of surprised me). Matt Hendricks smashed his stick on the glass in front of my face during warmup and then tied the game up late, so that was cool.
Amalie Arena once- wow, what a great arena. The plaza before you get in is really cool, there was a live band and other fun things. Nothing really exciting about the game itself, but the overall experience was great.
I also hope to get to MTS Centre, the Sattledome and Xcel Energy Center next year, but we'll see.
Some things I noticed writing that was I subconsciously focused on things not directly related to hockey (other entertainment options around the arena for one) whereas others in this thread I find were more into the feel of the building (the sound of Chicago Stadium, the seating at the Aud, etc). I wonder how much of a generational gap there is to appreciating hockey arenas differently. I've only been to modern NHL rinks so its what I'm used to and it limits me from having a different perspective on what a hockey arena "should" be like.