I have settled on a vintage game to share the radio broadcast of. And it might be the crown jewel of what's out there: The oldest known complete MLB radio broadcast in existence, the second annual MLB All-Star Game from 1934, taking place at the Polo Grounds in New York.
The starting lineups for both leagues brought serious star power, as 17 of the 18 starters would end up in the hall of fame (the only exception was the NL's starting center fielder, Wally Berger from the Braves, who had his career cut short due to injuries) and in total 28 of the 40 players named to the rosters (which includes both player/managers) were enshrined in Cooperstown. I believe that by the end of the game almost all of the future HOFers get at least one plate appearance or inning of work. I think there's just one lone player who doesn't make it in (Red Sox catcher Rick Ferrell)
The game also features a significant all-star game record that I can't mention without spoilers.
Your lineups (* indicates a future hall-of-famer)
American League
1) Charlie Gehringer* (2B/Detroit Tigers)
2) Heinie Manush* (LF/Washington Senators)
3) Babe Ruth* (RF/New York Yankees)
4) Lou Gehrig* (1B/New York Yankees)
5) Jimmie Foxx* (3B/Philadelphia Athletics)
6) Al Simmons* (CF/Chicago White Sox)
7) Joe Cronin* (SS/Washington Senators) ^Cronin was also the team's manager
8) Bill Dickey* (C/New York Yankees)
9) Lefty Gomez* (P/New York Yankees)
Reserves
Pitchers: Tommy Bridges (Detroit), Mel Harder (Cleveland), Red Ruffing* (New York), Jack Russell (Washington)
Position Players: C Mickey Cochrane* (Detroit), C Rick Ferrell* (Boston), 3B Jimmy Dykes (Chicago), 3B Pinky Higgins (Philadelphia), OF Earl Averill (Cleveland), OF Ben Chapman (New York), OF Sam West (St. Louis Browns)
National League
1) Frankie Frisch* (2B/St Louis Cardinals)
2) Pie Traynor* (3B/Pittsburgh Pirates)
3) Joe Medwick* (LF/St. Louis Cardinals)
4) Kiki Cuyler* (RF/Chicago Cubs)
5) Wally Berger (CF/Boston Braves)
6) Bill Terry* (1B/New York Giants) ^Terry was also the manager
7) Travis Jackson* (SS/New York Giants)
8) Gabby Hartnett* (C/Chicago Cubs)
9) Carl Hubbell* (P/New York Giants*
Reserves
Pitchers: Dizzy Dean* (St. Louis), Fred Frankhouse (Boston), Van Mungo (New York), Lon Warneke (Chicago)
Position Players: C Al Lopez* (New York), 2B Billy Herman* (Chicago), 3B Pepper Martin (Cardinals), SS Arky Vaughan* (Pittsburgh), OF Chuck Klein* (Chicago), OF Jo-Jo Moore (New York), OF Mel Ott* (New York), OF Paul Warner* (Pittsburgh)
I know I've posted this game before, but it was like 7 or 8 years ago and the youtube embed I used no longer exists. And there's a reasonable chance that some of the people here now may not have listened at the time.
@Da Cool Rula,
@MS,
@HockeyThoughts ,
@the valiant effort,
@td_ice,
@PanniniClaus,
@canucksfan,
@Blitzkrug,
@hockeywiz542,
@kb,
@torontoblood