It also proves how difficult drafting 18 year old kids is. The AHL is a huge step up from juniors/college, and then the NHL is another huge step up. And then, to be more than a bottom 6-er in the NHL is another big step. Trying to figure out if a kid will successfully navigate those two big steps and make it in the NHL is hard.
We saw his DY+1 at Boston College as a disappointment. Much more had been expected of him.
Statistically speaking, he got back to speed shortly thereafter and he certainly still looked promising in the 20-21 season, which was a covid-shortened year.
But ultimately, it always felt like he needed an entire season of AHL hockey in those early years - maybe two. This franchise didn't afford him that and the 21-22 season showed us that he was gonna need time, if not a different role altogether.
Things started ok in the 22-23 season, then slowed down, and then the injury came.
He was never the same after that ACL tear.
And it's why I'm not impressed when I watch a kid score a ton of easy goals in the pre-draft highlight videos. You get those in juniors/college and even in the AHL, but not in the NHL.
To be fair, Wahlstrom played at the U18 Worlds as an underager and put up 4-1-5 in 7 games, which is gooood for a 16-year-old. He went 7-2-9 in 7 games the spring thereafter, which was his draft year, in which he set USNTDP records with his 77 total goals.
As a light comparison, the top goalscorer in the program this year is McKinney with 39 total goals in 74 games.
And Wahlstrom's IO the entire time was that of a one-time threat who could also pick corners. Everything else was meh, but if you have guys who set others up, he was a sniper.
It seemed fully understandable that the Islanders selected him when he fell into their laps. He had already been a childhood YouTube video star to boot.
But the team obviously didn't realize how much he was in need of a sheltered prolonged, all-round transition to the pro game that would allow him to discover and work on everything he'd need in order to translate USNTDP success to the NHL level. He had deficiencies. They weren't dealt with.
In hindsight, he actually needed the Holmstrom treatment.
Who knows, maybe he'll get that now elsewhere and take a note out of the Daniel Sprong textbook to finding NHL work.