OT: NBA & Basketball - 2023-24 Season

17futurecap

Registered User
Oct 8, 2008
19,866
16,124
NJ
Knicks were up 98-89 in game 3 with under 10 to go, they scored 8 points the rest of the game.

They could have put the dagger in Indiana and didn’t, that was the series.
 

hi

Sell sell sell
May 23, 2008
7,613
5,089
Pacers 0 might be the most unlikeable athlete I've seen in years. All he does is complain and shake his head no all game
 

Brother Mouzone

Registered User
May 23, 2014
3,648
7,986
Being a Knicks fan is misery 99% of the time , that 1% that is good will not last . Hopefully this fuels a healthy team next year.
 

17futurecap

Registered User
Oct 8, 2008
19,866
16,124
NJ
It’s a very good roster, it’s still missing another star player. I just don’t think a Brunson, Randle and OG 3 are getting you all the way.

Be interesting what they do this summer, have to pay OG, him always being hurt is a worry. Have to decide on if they should go over the tax and pay Hartenstein, feel like they almost have to with how much time Robinson always misses.

It’s a letdown not getting to the ECF this year with Embiid on one leg, Jimmy Butler out and Giannis out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hi

mrmovies779

The Greatest Teacher,Failure is.
Feb 5, 2013
7,524
7,536
I like Hartenstein a lot but some team will throw an outrageous contract at him and I hope the Knicks don't get crazy trying to resign him
 
  • Like
Reactions: klingsor

noncents

Registered User
Feb 25, 2022
1,655
2,067
let's see brunson randle and OG play together before saying they can't win anything
 

mrmovies779

The Greatest Teacher,Failure is.
Feb 5, 2013
7,524
7,536
Losing Robinson was such a huge blow.Nobody in the league can protect the paint like he does.Hartenstein is ok,but teams don't think twice about driving into him.If only this team was at full force....aaaah,what could have been...
 

CTTribe73

Registered User
Aug 17, 2023
510
531
I like Hartenstein a lot but some team will throw an outrageous contract at him and I hope the Knicks don't get crazy trying to resign him
If our team had been fully healthy we would have kicked the ever living shit out of Indiana. That's TWICE they got lucky with injuries; first round the Bucks had a heavily compromised Lillard and were without Giannis.

They are frauds. Holiday will put Tyrese Halitosis in jail.
 

Oscar Lindberg

Registered User
Dec 14, 2015
16,120
15,583
CA
Other thing the Knicks have to figure out is Randle

They won’t win with him playing meaningful minutes. I know people want to talk themselves into him being different, but he’s not.

How many times does he have to prove he’s not that guy before people realize? lol
 

Rangerfan4life90

Registered User
Oct 14, 2008
10,686
2,510
College Point, NY
It’s a very good roster, it’s still missing another star player. I just don’t think a Brunson, Randle and OG 3 are getting you all the way.

Be interesting what they do this summer, have to pay OG, him always being hurt is a worry. Have to decide on if they should go over the tax and pay Hartenstein, feel like they almost have to with how much time Robinson always misses.

It’s a letdown not getting to the ECF this year with Embiid on one leg, Jimmy Butler out and Giannis out.
Even if they won this series and made it to the ECF, they had 0 shot of beating Boston with the amount of injuries they had. Ever since Randle went down back in like early Feb, the injuries just kept on piling since - it's insane.

Like MH said, if they have a good offseason and have much better luck with injuries next season, they'll contend deeply.

Other thing the Knicks have to figure out is Randle

They won’t win with him playing meaningful minutes. I know people want to talk themselves into him being different, but he’s not.

How many times does he have to prove he’s not that guy before people realize? lol
1) Brunson is officially the guy, not Randle

2) We never saw this year's version of Randle in the playoffs, so it is not valid to say that. Randle would have made a big difference in the Pacers series, for example.
 
Dec 10, 2007
25,141
6,301
Saville Row
RkPlayerAgeGGSMPFGFGAFG%3P3PA3P%2P2PA2P%eFG%FTFTAFT%ORBDRBTRBASTSTLBLKTOVPFPTS
1Luol Deng25828239.16.514.1.4601.44.1.3455.110.0.506.5103.14.1.7531.44.45.82.81.00.61.92.017.4
2Derrick Rose22818137.48.819.7.4451.64.8.3327.215.0.481.4855.96.9.8581.03.14.17.71.00.63.41.725.0
3Joakim Noah25484832.84.48.4.5250.00.0.0004.48.4.526.5252.93.9.7393.86.610.42.21.01.51.93.311.7
4Carlos Boozer29595931.9

RkPlayerAgeGGSMPFGFGAFG%3P3PA3P%2P2PA2P%eFG%FTFTAFT%ORBDRBTRBASTSTLBLKTOVPFPTS
1Julius Randle29464635.48.618.2.4721.75.3.3116.912.9.539.5185.16.6.7812.27.09.25.00.50.33.52.724.0
2Jalen Brunson27777735.410.321.4.4792.76.8.4017.514.6.516.5435.56.5.8470.63.13.66.70.90.22.41.928.7
3OG Anunoby26232334.95.411.1.4881.84.5.3943.76.6.553.5681.51.9.7911.03.44.41.51.71.01.72.514.1
4Josh Hart28814233.4

The Knicks weren't unlucky with injuries and (if they bring Thibs back) they won't do better next season. Since Thibs rookie season in 2010-11 he's been playing his top 4 players too much and grinding them down leading to injuries and playoff losses. He doesn't play the bench enough. This is well known. Thanks to him D. Rose may become the first MVP ever to not make the Hall of Fame.
 

RangerBlues

Registered User
Apr 27, 2004
4,780
824
BRONX NYC
The Knicks weren't unlucky with injuries and (if they bring Thibs back) they won't do better next season. Since Thibs rookie season in 2010-11 he's been playing his top 4 players too much and grinding them down leading to injuries and playoff losses. He doesn't play the bench enough. This is well known. Thanks to him D. Rose may become the first MVP ever to not make the Hall of Fame.
If Randle played enough games to qualify the Knicks would have four players in the top thirty in minutes played. To be fair, they traded away a lot of depth to get better players. Robinson being constantly broken did not help. Bogdonovic was brough in to give minutes. Then he broke. Hartenstein was already playing way too many for. And everyone else cant defend or is a work in progress.
This is going to be a very different team next season.
 

RangerBlues

Registered User
Apr 27, 2004
4,780
824
BRONX NYC
If you had stopped after the first sentence, your post would have been perfect. As I demonstrated in my first post, this is a historic trend by Thibs. His top players have played too much since 2010, that's why they get hurt. Research it. There's no unlucky or accidental injuries on his teams. It's all caused by years of abuse. This is well-known. Brunson is not headed for the Basketball HoF (there is no NBA HoF) for this reason. He just had hand surgery.
I had to continue because your statement had zero context.
The team had minutes depth.
Those players were not good enough.
Got better players.
Sacrificed lineup depth.
Loose Randal ,Robinson, Bogdonovitch. all 30 min a game players.
The rest of the team cant defend anybody.
He played those guys because he had no other options.
You could play some rotation and then loose to philly in the first round.
Or grind the team to dust to game 7 against a deeper and younger indy team.
I have zero desire to get swept by Boston after that.
Next season will have a very different team.
 

CTTribe73

Registered User
Aug 17, 2023
510
531
I had to continue because your statement had zero context.
The team had minutes depth.
Those players were not good enough.
Got better players.
Sacrificed lineup depth.
Loose Randal ,Robinson, Bogdonovitch. all 30 min a game players.
The rest of the team cant defend anybody.
He played those guys because he had no other options.
You could play some rotation and then loose to philly in the first round.
Or grind the team to dust to game 7 against a deeper and younger indy team.
I have zero desire to get swept by Boston after that.
Next season will have a very different team.
If you go back in the history of the NBA to before Thibs got his first HC job with the Bulls, superstars where routinely playing 38-40+ minutes per game. I think in the 01-02 season Iverson averaged 42. Other guys that were up there: Elton Brand, Kobe Bryant, Karl Malone etc. Yes this was long before the benefits of periodic rest had been analytically proven.....however, superstars still play max minutes when they're on the court now the only difference is they take entire games off which isn't IMO a great answer-and the NBA agrees.

Thibs was't responsible for the injuries this season unless you adopt the nonsensical and extremist view that merely having a player on the court exposes them to injury. But I guess then the only answer is to put them in bubble wrap the minute the contract is signed and only let them play in the playoffs.

Extend Thibs. He earned it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KevinFinnerty

Machinehead

HFNYR MVP
Jan 21, 2011
148,102
126,968
NYC
1000003957.jpg
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad