Stephen
Moderator
- Feb 28, 2002
- 83,099
- 62,018
all of them. who won. [which, congrats to them], won playing on teams where they were placed in their ideal situation. Dion wasn't captain and first pair D for Ottawa. Bozak wasn't 1st line centre. Kessel was not the first line winger and the star of the show. and it seems that Kadri rightly got the kick in the pants he needed after being traded and was connecting with his line.
They weren't the stars, they weren't the main horses, they were where they needed to to be, playing the roles the should have, probably for the most part being paid normal amounts of money (those who signed in UFA). and I am only speaking for myself. Again, I think Kessel has a very short shelf life with teams. See Boston, see here, see Pittsburgh. my isssue with him was never about his playoff performances. I personally didn't want bozak to go but we couldn't afford him, and Naz was a flipping dipstick in both playoff runs and I personally don't blame management after they talked to him and promising he learned his lesson to take the same kind of penalty, in the same freaking corner basically around the same time as the last one, being extremely apprehensive about him being on the team. [not. as people love lament. "the team is marshallmallowy soft, etc etc." but whatever].
let's not pretend that if they all stayed here together, we were winning it all.
Toronto is as "insufferable" to play in as other major markets with a big historic past, and I would say as insufferable as Toronto is, it's still easier than a lot of the other markets because at the end of the day it's all hot noise. most of the "pressure" goes away if someone makes a big hit here. the pressure isn't even to win a cup here anymore, it's just to win a playoff series. you think that would fly in New York, or Boston, or Philadelphia or England for any of the soccer clubs?
at any rate. congrats to Naz for winning. I am sincerely glad he did, and that more importantly got his poop together and played extremely well.
Well said Daisy.
Guys like Larry Murphy, Phil Kessel, Tyler Bozak (but maybe not Nazem Kadri) all had to go somewhere else and slotted lower on the pecking order to win a cup. Hell, even Luke Schenn went somewhere and won some cups. Doesn't mean it was wrong that Toronto gave up on them, or that when you give up on a player they can't achieve big things in their career somewhere else.
That said, I think the biggest problem with Larry Murphy and Nazem Kadri being traded is more of an issue of what we got back, and the fact that management made a change for the sake of change. I'm happy to see Naz have success, but he was also a bit of a problem child when he was here. He was our guy and we could have stuck with him, or not. And at the end of the day we didn't get the right value and return back to help us win a cup. Bottom line, that's the only issue for me.