The part that keeps making me shake me head is we are the oldest team in the league. We've got "great locker room guy, cup champion, leader, culture setter" type guys coming out the wazoo. Coming out flat every single night anyway. I don't know how anyone (cough ownership cough) can look at this and blame anyone but the coach and GM - it ain't the players!
As a side note, I do think the "locker room presence" thing weighs too heavily in fans' evaluation of players. We don't know what happens in the locker room, and I'm sure there are plenty of guys that are known as captain material but aren't at all, and vice versa. Let's go get talent instead, for now.