HFBS
Noted Troublemaker
- Jan 18, 2015
- 2,192
- 2,252
My Ranger Playoff Report Card
- Thread starter HFBS
- Start date
-
Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
EdJovanovski
#FreeRempe
Chris Kreider - C+
Mika Zibanejad - C-
Jack Roslovic - C-
Artemi Panarin - B
Vincent Trocheck - A
Alexis Lafreniere - A
Will Cuylle - C+
Alex Wennberg - C
Kaapo Kakko - F
Filip Chytil - F
Barclay Goodrow - A
Matt Rempe - A
Jimmy Vesey - C
Adam Fox - C
Ryan Lindgren - C
Jacob Trouba - F
K’Andre Miller - C
Erik Gustafsson - C
Braden Schneider - C
Igor Shesterkin - A
Mika Zibanejad - C-
Jack Roslovic - C-
Artemi Panarin - B
Vincent Trocheck - A
Alexis Lafreniere - A
Will Cuylle - C+
Alex Wennberg - C
Kaapo Kakko - F
Filip Chytil - F
Barclay Goodrow - A
Matt Rempe - A
Jimmy Vesey - C
Adam Fox - C
Ryan Lindgren - C
Jacob Trouba - F
K’Andre Miller - C
Erik Gustafsson - C
Braden Schneider - C
Igor Shesterkin - A
ReddestRum
Sad even when winning
- Dec 19, 2013
- 3,989
- 5,408
Trouba with a higher score over Miller is just some weird shit.
This is probably closer to my take on things. Like this one.
This is probably closer to my take on things. Like this one.
DanielBrassard
It's all so tiresome
Everyone but Igor, Laf, Trocheck, and Fox get an F.
For f*** off.
For f*** off.
Chris Kreider - C+
Mika Zibanejad - D
Jack Roslovic - C-
Artemi Panarin - D-
Vincent Trocheck - A +
Alexis Lafreniere - A +
Will Cuylle - C+
Alex Wennberg - D -
Kaapo Kakko - D-
Filip Chytil - B- (considering how much time he missed, he was noticeable and has some chances)
Barclay Goodrow - A
Matt Rempe - A
Jimmy Vesey - B- PK looked lost after his injury
Adam Fox - C (he was hurt most of the playoffs)
Ryan Lindgren - C
Jacob Trouba - F-
K’Andre Miller - D-
Erik Gustafsson - D
Braden Schneider - B-
Igor Shesterkin - A+++
Mika Zibanejad - D
Jack Roslovic - C-
Artemi Panarin - D-
Vincent Trocheck - A +
Alexis Lafreniere - A +
Will Cuylle - C+
Alex Wennberg - D -
Kaapo Kakko - D-
Filip Chytil - B- (considering how much time he missed, he was noticeable and has some chances)
Barclay Goodrow - A
Matt Rempe - A
Jimmy Vesey - B- PK looked lost after his injury
Adam Fox - C (he was hurt most of the playoffs)
Ryan Lindgren - C
Jacob Trouba - F-
K’Andre Miller - D-
Erik Gustafsson - D
Braden Schneider - B-
Igor Shesterkin - A+++
Lindgren is a f***ing F------------------
It is hard to be that bad, its even harder to be that bad playing with a top 3 (2?) player at the position in the sport.
It's amazing the leeway a player will get if they take a big hit and return despite being terrible before and after the big hit. He sucked in the regular season and was even worse in the playoffs.
It is hard to be that bad, its even harder to be that bad playing with a top 3 (2?) player at the position in the sport.
It's amazing the leeway a player will get if they take a big hit and return despite being terrible before and after the big hit. He sucked in the regular season and was even worse in the playoffs.
Whoot Whoot
Biased Rangers Fan
Megustaelhockey
"I like hockey" in Spanish
- Apr 29, 2011
- 23,426
- 17,553
Grades will obviously be very different between the regular season and playoffs. Let me sleep on it first.
n8
WAAAAAAA!!!
Chris Kreider - B (bumped his score up for his epic game 6 vs Carolina)
Mika Zibanejad - D (earned the moniker Zibanebad. What happened to his Stamkos slapper?)
Jack Roslovic - F+ (some of you love his speed, this guy was totally useless in my eyes. always lost the puck avoid hits, never skates hard unless he's celebrating a goal, loses all the puck battles by never showing up to them.
Artemi Panarin - C- (breadman is the soggy breadman)
Vincent Trocheck - A
Alexis Lafreniere - A
Will Cuylle - C (like I was aware of him and yet he was invisible)
Alex Wennberg - D (another softie, better than Roslovic but really a nothing burger of a player)
Kaapo Kakko - D (he had chances, he just managed to flub every one of them)
Filip Chytil - D (in and out after such a long injury. Kinda want to give him an incomplete)
Barclay Goodrow - A- (overperformed is the word)
Matt Rempe - C+ (fell down way too much, didn't bring the pain)
Jimmy Vesey - C (HIMMY)
Adam Fox - C (injured, saw none of his signature blue line dancing)
Ryan Lindgren - C (I mean he probably performed up to his ability if you know what I mean)
Jacob Trouba - F (Trouba Train did not show up. Only Trouba Trainwreck.)
K’Andre Miller - C- (wildly inconsistent)
Erik Gustafsson - C- (felt like he folded in the playoffs once he experienced some puck pressure)
Braden Schneider - B- (I think he did alright for a young 3rd pairing guy)
Igor Shesterkin - A
Mika Zibanejad - D (earned the moniker Zibanebad. What happened to his Stamkos slapper?)
Jack Roslovic - F+ (some of you love his speed, this guy was totally useless in my eyes. always lost the puck avoid hits, never skates hard unless he's celebrating a goal, loses all the puck battles by never showing up to them.
Artemi Panarin - C- (breadman is the soggy breadman)
Vincent Trocheck - A
Alexis Lafreniere - A
Will Cuylle - C (like I was aware of him and yet he was invisible)
Alex Wennberg - D (another softie, better than Roslovic but really a nothing burger of a player)
Kaapo Kakko - D (he had chances, he just managed to flub every one of them)
Filip Chytil - D (in and out after such a long injury. Kinda want to give him an incomplete)
Barclay Goodrow - A- (overperformed is the word)
Matt Rempe - C+ (fell down way too much, didn't bring the pain)
Jimmy Vesey - C (HIMMY)
Adam Fox - C (injured, saw none of his signature blue line dancing)
Ryan Lindgren - C (I mean he probably performed up to his ability if you know what I mean)
Jacob Trouba - F (Trouba Train did not show up. Only Trouba Trainwreck.)
K’Andre Miller - C- (wildly inconsistent)
Erik Gustafsson - C- (felt like he folded in the playoffs once he experienced some puck pressure)
Braden Schneider - B- (I think he did alright for a young 3rd pairing guy)
Igor Shesterkin - A
For this series or all of the playoffs? Because if it's for all of the playoffs even I say that's a bit much. They made the ECF and didn't have to go to a game 7 in either for series we won.
DanielBrassard
It's all so tiresome
First series was a joke, Washington was awful and the rangers didn’t even play that well. Carolina is whatever, it’s obvious whatever they do doesn’t work in the playoffs. I’m really not interested in celebrating the first two series. Team failed, and they were exposed again by Florida.
Pass with distinction - Laf, Tro, Goodrow, Igor
Pass - Everybody else
Fail - Panarin, Mika (not including Caps series), Fox (injury), Kakko, Wennburg (warm body)
It's a real shame that Fox was hobbled so badly. What might have been if he'd have been anything close to 100%.
It's also a real shame that Panarin was so ineffective for such long periods. I'd happily take an 80-point regular season guy who can actually play his game in the post season over him at this point.
Still... It was a treat to see Laf shine, fun to watch Goodrow make up for a poor regular season and great seeing Trocheck be such a pest/clutch guy. Igor was Igor.
Pass - Everybody else
Fail - Panarin, Mika (not including Caps series), Fox (injury), Kakko, Wennburg (warm body)
It's a real shame that Fox was hobbled so badly. What might have been if he'd have been anything close to 100%.
It's also a real shame that Panarin was so ineffective for such long periods. I'd happily take an 80-point regular season guy who can actually play his game in the post season over him at this point.
Still... It was a treat to see Laf shine, fun to watch Goodrow make up for a poor regular season and great seeing Trocheck be such a pest/clutch guy. Igor was Igor.
- Nov 14, 2018
- 4,062
- 8,870
Lavi - F
Not for getting us to the playoffs (as that was an “A”), but for the sheer bloody-mindedness of refusing to split the bromance of Mika-Kreider or change PP1 when it had clearly been “figured out”. He was outcoached in the ECF and had no Plan B.
Not for getting us to the playoffs (as that was an “A”), but for the sheer bloody-mindedness of refusing to split the bromance of Mika-Kreider or change PP1 when it had clearly been “figured out”. He was outcoached in the ECF and had no Plan B.
Chris Kreider - C+
Mika Zibanejad - D
Jack Roslovic - D
Artemi Panarin - D
Vincent Trocheck - A
Alexis Lafreniere - A
Will Cuylle - C
Alex Wennberg - C
Kaapo Kakko - D
Filip Chytil - C-
Barclay Goodrow - A
Matt Rempe - B
Jimmy Vesey - D
Adam Fox - C
Ryan Lindgren - C
Jacob Trouba - F
K’Andre Miller - F
Erik Gustafsson - F
Braden Schneider - C
Igor Shesterkin - A+
Mika Zibanejad - D
Jack Roslovic - D
Artemi Panarin - D
Vincent Trocheck - A
Alexis Lafreniere - A
Will Cuylle - C
Alex Wennberg - C
Kaapo Kakko - D
Filip Chytil - C-
Barclay Goodrow - A
Matt Rempe - B
Jimmy Vesey - D
Adam Fox - C
Ryan Lindgren - C
Jacob Trouba - F
K’Andre Miller - F
Erik Gustafsson - F
Braden Schneider - C
Igor Shesterkin - A+
Crease
Chief Justice of the HFNYR Court
- Jul 12, 2004
- 24,760
- 27,696
Igor A
Trocheck A
Lafreniere A
Goodrow A
Schneider B
Fox C
Cuylle C
Kreider C
Panarin C
Miller C
Lindgren D
Zibanejad D
Roslovic D
Wennberg D
Kakko D
Chytil D
Vesey D
Rempe D
Brodzinski D
Gustafsson F
Trouba F
Quick - Incomplete
Jones - Incomplete
Ruhwedal - Incomplete
Trocheck A
Lafreniere A
Goodrow A
Schneider B
Fox C
Cuylle C
Kreider C
Panarin C
Miller C
Lindgren D
Zibanejad D
Roslovic D
Wennberg D
Kakko D
Chytil D
Vesey D
Rempe D
Brodzinski D
Gustafsson F
Trouba F
Quick - Incomplete
Jones - Incomplete
Ruhwedal - Incomplete
Rangerboy030
Registered User
- Apr 21, 2012
- 2,192
- 2,790
Panarin - B
Zibanejad - D
Kreider - C
Trocheck - A
Chytil - N/A
Goodrow - A
Lafreniere - A
Rempe - C
Vesey - D
Brodzinski - N/A
Kakko - D
Roslovic - C
Wennberg - D
Wheeler - N/A
Cuylle - C
Fox - C
Trouba - D
Miller - C
Lindgren - F
Schneider - C
Gustafsson - C
Shesterkin - A
Laviolette - B
Zibanejad - D
Kreider - C
Trocheck - A
Chytil - N/A
Goodrow - A
Lafreniere - A
Rempe - C
Vesey - D
Brodzinski - N/A
Kakko - D
Roslovic - C
Wennberg - D
Wheeler - N/A
Cuylle - C
Fox - C
Trouba - D
Miller - C
Lindgren - F
Schneider - C
Gustafsson - C
Shesterkin - A
Laviolette - B
Last edited:
Panarin - C
Zibanejad - C+
Kreider - B
Trocheck - A+
Chytil - N/A
Goodrow - A
Lafreniere - A
Rempe - C-
Vesey - D
Brodzinski - N/A
Kakko - C-
Roslovic - C+
Wennberg - D
Wheeler - N/A
Fox - B
Trouba - F
Miller - C+
Lindgren - F---------------
Schneider - C+
Gustafsson - C-
Shesterkin - A-
Shesterkin with an excellent series and showing overall but despite being pretty heavily out played, the Florida series was one that he could have stolen and gained legend status had stopped a few shots that he almost always stops. It doesn't completely diminish the performance overall as he had plenty of shots he stopped that he shouldn't have but you can't ignore the bad ones that he let in either.
Outside of the obvious bias for some players this is surprisingly good.
Zibanejad - C+
Kreider - B
Trocheck - A+
Chytil - N/A
Goodrow - A
Lafreniere - A
Rempe - C-
Vesey - D
Brodzinski - N/A
Kakko - C-
Roslovic - C+
Wennberg - D
Wheeler - N/A
Fox - B
Trouba - F
Miller - C+
Lindgren - F---------------
Schneider - C+
Gustafsson - C-
Shesterkin - A-
Shesterkin with an excellent series and showing overall but despite being pretty heavily out played, the Florida series was one that he could have stolen and gained legend status had stopped a few shots that he almost always stops. It doesn't completely diminish the performance overall as he had plenty of shots he stopped that he shouldn't have but you can't ignore the bad ones that he let in either.
Outside of the obvious bias for some players this is surprisingly good.
CommaSynapse
Registered User
- Nov 2, 2013
- 5,170
- 2,825
I give Schneider a lot of credit. I'm surprised to see his ratings so low.
Not exactly an A performance based on turnovers and that, but considering he got shoved into a top-4 role (and with Miller, to boot) because the Trouba-Miller pairing was playing so poorly, I thought he did an admirable job, all things considered.
He showed a lot more 2-way play in the playoffs, and he wasn't hesitant to join in down low or get physical, and both of those things were sorely needed against a team like the Panthers.
Considering he won't be 23 until September, I think he's on track for a big step next year.
One of the bright spots for me. Still things to iron out, but he showed capability.
Not exactly an A performance based on turnovers and that, but considering he got shoved into a top-4 role (and with Miller, to boot) because the Trouba-Miller pairing was playing so poorly, I thought he did an admirable job, all things considered.
He showed a lot more 2-way play in the playoffs, and he wasn't hesitant to join in down low or get physical, and both of those things were sorely needed against a team like the Panthers.
Considering he won't be 23 until September, I think he's on track for a big step next year.
One of the bright spots for me. Still things to iron out, but he showed capability.
PuckLuck3043
Stairway To Heaven
Yup. All he did was keep rotating Chytil, Rempe, Wheeler. No real changes, No 11/7 and maybe try Jones for a few shifts, no putting Laf on PP 1 since they were 1 for 15. Terrible job. Gallant 2.0.
HC Laviolette D Installing no Wheels Wheeler into a critical playoff game 5 and then starting with that terribile line in OT.
Florida Panthers A+ They completely dominated the series. Forechecking, board battles, O zone time of possession and penaly kill. The Rangers were just outclassed as they were in the Carolina series but Shesterkin stole that series.
The Rangers have one good line and they were shutdown this series when it counted.
The better team won and the only reason it was close was because of Igor's play. The whole team is soft other than Trouba. They are an easy team to play against in the playoffs.
Florida was better and they deserved to win.
Florida Panthers A+ They completely dominated the series. Forechecking, board battles, O zone time of possession and penaly kill. The Rangers were just outclassed as they were in the Carolina series but Shesterkin stole that series.
The Rangers have one good line and they were shutdown this series when it counted.
The better team won and the only reason it was close was because of Igor's play. The whole team is soft other than Trouba. They are an easy team to play against in the playoffs.
Florida was better and they deserved to win.
Megustaelhockey
"I like hockey" in Spanish
- Apr 29, 2011
- 23,426
- 17,553
Igor RS: B+, PO: A
Trocheck RS: B+, PO: A-
Lafreniere RS: B+, PO: A
Goodrow RS: C+, PO: A-
Schneider RS: B-, PO: B
Fox RS: B+, PO: C
Cuylle RS: B-, PO: C
Kreider RS: B, PO: B-
Panarin RS: A, PO: C+
Miller RS: B-, PO: C-
Lindgren RS: C, PO: D
Zibanejad RS: B-, PO: D
Roslovic RS: Inc., PO: C-
Wennberg RS: Inc., PO: C+
Kakko RS: C-, PO: D
Chytil RS: Inc., PO: C+
Vesey RS: B+, PO: C-
Rempe RS: Inc., PO: C+
Brodzinski RS: C, PO: C
Gustafsson RS: B-, PO: C-
Trouba RS: D, PO: F
Quick RS: B+, PO: Inc.
Jones - RS: B-, PO: Inc.
Ruhwedel - RS: Inc., PO: Inc.
Trocheck RS: B+, PO: A-
Lafreniere RS: B+, PO: A
Goodrow RS: C+, PO: A-
Schneider RS: B-, PO: B
Fox RS: B+, PO: C
Cuylle RS: B-, PO: C
Kreider RS: B, PO: B-
Panarin RS: A, PO: C+
Miller RS: B-, PO: C-
Lindgren RS: C, PO: D
Zibanejad RS: B-, PO: D
Roslovic RS: Inc., PO: C-
Wennberg RS: Inc., PO: C+
Kakko RS: C-, PO: D
Chytil RS: Inc., PO: C+
Vesey RS: B+, PO: C-
Rempe RS: Inc., PO: C+
Brodzinski RS: C, PO: C
Gustafsson RS: B-, PO: C-
Trouba RS: D, PO: F
Quick RS: B+, PO: Inc.
Jones - RS: B-, PO: Inc.
Ruhwedel - RS: Inc., PO: Inc.
Last edited:
SeanAveryTheGreatOne
Registered User
- Jul 4, 2021
- 861
- 1,736
1. An $8M/year captain getting a "D+" from someone who isn't sour on him is still dreadful.
2. Miller was better the first half of the playoffs... because he was away from Trouba. Trouba demonstrably makes Miller worse.
Ad
Upcoming events
-
-
PICK ONLY ONE TEAM - 4 Nations Face-Off - ChampionWagers: 17Staked: $15,090.00Event closes- Updated:
-
-
USA vs Finland - Centre Bell, MontréalWagers: 5Staked: $1,962.00Event closes - 2 days from now
- Updated:
-
Finland vs Sweden - Centre Bell, MontréalWagers: 3Staked: $387.00Event closes - 4 days from now
- Updated: