Proposal: MTL & UTAH

[Lockin17]

MTL : Guhle + #78 + Ylonen
for
Utah : #6

Click to read more...

 

[SR]

MTL : Guhle + #78 + Ylonen
for
Utah : #6

No

 

[Lockin17]

No

well Utah called it out saying they wanted to trade their #6 .
Guhle makes a lot of sense

 

[Miller Time]

MTL : Guhle + #78 + Ylonen
for
Utah : #6

No from Mtl

 

[DustyDangler]

MTL : Guhle + #78 + Ylonen
for
Utah : #6

Having a Ylonen with a Doan again would be fun.

 

[Xirik]

time to go through the list of other teams Utah could get a defenseman with their 6th

1. Sharks = Mukhamadullin +?
2. Vegas = sign and trade Theodore?
3. Avs = Girard +
4. Stars = Harley sign and trade?
5.Jackets = Svozil + +

and the habs proposal.

 

[dirtydanglez]

maybe to nj for #10

 

[Jeune Poulet]

No from Mtl

I for one would take this deal.

Who knows... if Guhle's lucky, he might even manage to carry his suitcase to the airport without injuring himself.

 

[JRichard]

MTL : Guhle + #78 + Ylonen
for
Utah : #6

Imagine leaving the draft with 5 (Demidov-Lindstrom) and 6 (Iginla) or a better d than Guhle in 3 years.
Habs need one of Hutson, Mailloux, Reinbacher, Barron to hit and Guhle will be quickly forgotten.

 

[SR]

well Utah called it out saying they wanted to trade their #6 .
Guhle makes a lot of sense

Guhle isn’t a top pairing defenseman.

 

[jfhabs]

Guhle isn’t a top pairing defenseman.

Not now , but he's closer right now than anyone you're drafting at 6

 

[Mersss]

time to go through the list of other teams Utah could get a defenseman with their 6th

1. Sharks = Mukhamadullin +?
2. Vegas = sign and trade Theodore?
3. Avs = Girard +
4. Stars = Harley sign and trade?
5.Jackets = Svozil + +

and the habs proposal.

Guhle is better than every single D named above minus Thedore who's close to 30

Guhle isn’t a top pairing defenseman.

Weird. He played top pairing all year vs the other teams top line and was pretty good at it.

Same at the WC...

You do realise the primary goal of a D is to defend right? Not all about having 80pts seasons

 

[Mosby]

well Utah called it out saying they wanted to trade their #6 .

Utah made no such statement

 

[bleuetbio]

Dont think we'll ever consider to trade Guhle for a magic bean

 

[Ledge And Dairy]

time to go through the list of other teams Utah could get a defenseman with their 6th

1. Sharks = Mukhamadullin +?
2. Vegas = sign and trade Theodore?
3. Avs = Girard +
4. Stars = Harley sign and trade?
5.Jackets = Svozil + +

and the habs proposal.

Or they could literally just draft one with a higher ceiling than all of those

 

[Mrb1p]

Lol, who's the last D like Guhle to be traded ? What was the value he returned ?

Guhle isn’t a top pairing defenseman.

You're right, he's a bonafide number one.

 

[PajamaBoy]

Jesus christ

 

[HabsAddict]

Guhle is a proven young NHL defenseman and not only are we giving him up, we are adding more to get a magic bean at 6th.

Makes a lot of sense...said no GM in history.

If this was last year and we're talking 3rd OA and getting Fantilli, I would drive Guhle to the airport, but this year with everyone and his dog doing nothing but guessing, a big fat NO.

 

[a mangy Meowth]

Ridiculous lol

 

[CapSpace]

I like Guhle a lot, but if Utah offer this, you gotta at least listen and think about it.

 

[The Don Hughes]

MTL : Guhle + #78 + Ylonen
for
Utah : #6

I just don't see Guhle having this kind of value

 

[bud12]

time to go through the list of other teams Utah could get a defenseman with their 6th

1. Sharks = Mukhamadullin +?
2. Vegas = sign and trade Theodore?
3. Avs = Girard +
4. Stars = Harley sign and trade?
5.Jackets = Svozil + +

and the habs proposal.

Are those guys supposed to be better than Guhle?

 

[Miller Time]

I for one would take this deal.

Who knows... if Guhle's lucky, he might even manage to carry his suitcase to the airport without injuring himself.

Sure...

5 years from now, let's revisit to see how many NHL games Dmen picked 4-8 have played in the NHL, and compare that to how many Guhle will have played...

He's arguably the best d man from the 2020 draft class, it's frankly silly to expect a dman available at 6OA this year will be a better NHLer. Typical shiny new toy draft class assessment.

 

[CanadienShark]

Both sides say no. Guhle is too important to Montreal now and in the future. Utah says no because Guhle isn't quite worth that pick in a pure value sense.

 

[Xirik]

Are those guys supposed to be better than Guhle?

are + signs meaningless?