Proposal: MTL & UTAH

[Alikhan Alizada]

5TH overall pick this year for Dylan Guenter.

Would Arizona do it?

Dylan Guenter looks like a future star I my eyes and has produced very well in his first 78 games in the nhl(50 points) and Arizona could select a high end D with Habs pick.

Trying to see the value here I would be willing to add a little from mtl side.

Click to read more...

 

[Mrfenn92]

Don’t see Arizona moving on from guenther

 

[Ledge And Dairy]

No incentive for Utah to do this. They can already select a high end D with their own pick. And considering it's the same scouting staff as last year they are probably circling on Silayev. I would be surprised if he's gone before their pick

 

[Heldig]

5TH overall pick this year for Dylan Guenter.

Would Arizona do it?

Dylan Guenter looks like a future star I my eyes and has produced very well in his first 78 games in the nhl(50 points) and Arizona could select a high end D with Habs pick.

Trying to see the value here I would be willing to add a little from mtl side.

Why would UTAH consider that? They pick one spot after the Habs (pending lottery outcomes) and will be drafting a high end D already.

 

[Brodeur]

Doesn't seem like something that would make sense for Utah. Tendency when a team gets a new owner is to be a buyer.

 

[Baksfamous112]

Unless Utah wants to be in a perpetual rebuild, which I doubt they do, I don’t see how or why they would do that

 

[SR]

Absolutely not. Wouldn’t trade Guenther for Celebrini, either. Guenther is going to be very very good.

 

[Junohockeyfan]

Absolutely not. Wouldn’t trade Guenther for Celebrini, either. Guenther is going to be very very good.

What about Connor Mcdavid? Would you lower your ask for Connor?

 

[SR]

What about Connor Mcdavid? Would you lower your ask for Connor?

Typical bs post. Move along

 

[Chainshot]

Yet another proposal that has no incentive for the trading team to send their player to Montreal. Well done.

 

[rt]

5TH overall pick this year for Dylan Guenter.

Would Arizona do it?

Dylan Guenter looks like a future star I my eyes and has produced very well in his first 78 games in the nhl(50 points) and Arizona could select a high end D with Habs pick.

Trying to see the value here I would be willing to add a little from mtl side.

Utah says no thanks. Just take Iginla 5th if you want a goal scoring winger.

 

[Junohockeyfan]

Typical bs post. Move along

Says the guy who wouldn’t trade Guenther for Celebrini…. what are you smoking?

 

[JustAHabFan]

Absolutely not. Wouldn’t trade Guenther for Celebrini, either. Guenther is going to be very very good.

Wow. Really? Don't need to worry about it. Whoever own the 1st overall pick will never trade that pick for Guenther.

 

[SR]

Says the guy who wouldn’t trade Guenther for Celebrini…. what are you smoking?

I wouldn’t. Guenther and his potential isn’t worth a gamble. He’s already shown he can score in this league. Plays the right way and hasn’t even put in a full year.

This forward draft class is weak. Celebrini plays the more prominent position, but Guenther is already established at a very young age.

 

[SR]

Guenther put up 35pts in 45 games and was a -1 on a horrendously bad defensive team. Celebrini, who likely will pan out, I’d imagine, may end up like Shane Wright.

Don’t let the hype and the 1OA fool you. We’ve seen it too many times.

 

[BKarchitect]

There’s no chance that Utah deals Guenther for #5.

If Utah fans want to say they wouldn’t deal him for Celebrini, that’s fine but comparing Celebrini to Shane Wright is just a bad, uniformed take.

 

[God]

Utah has Keller (25), Crouse (26), Maccelli (22), Cooley (19), Guenther (20), and Moser (23) as a solid young core already.They already have Simashev/But/Geekie waiting in the wings. It's a step backwards if they trade Guenther for an 18 year old that probably needs 2-3 years to reach a good level of production (see: Hughes, Lafreniere), and while you'd probably think for a bit on a Guenther for Celebrini trade, you definitely don't need to think about a Guenther for 5th overall trade because you get an even lesser chance at a good outcome from the pick.

 

[Dog]

There’s no chance that Utah deals Guenther for #5.

If Utah fans want to say they wouldn’t deal him for Celebrini, that’s fine but comparing Celebrini to Shane Wright is just a bad, uniformed take.

Yeah give Macklin a chance first and assuming if they NHL draft lottery holds he is going to San Jose. Well Wright is not done yet either he just starting to warm up and probably will see more NHL games next year. He is not a dud!

 

[bud12]

Trading #5 for Guenther? Hell yeah!!! Don't know why would Utah accept that thought. Trading Guenther for the pick hopping the pick become like Guenther lol

 

[SR]

There’s no chance that Utah deals Guenther for #5.

If Utah fans want to say they wouldn’t deal him for Celebrini, that’s fine but comparing Celebrini to Shane Wright is just a bad, uniformed take.

If you read it correctly, you’d notice I didn’t compare the player, I compared the hype of a 1OA pick and what it can translate into. I’ll take a .88 point player that is good defensively with a elite release and speed that has proven he can play in the NHL over a very promising college center that hasn’t played a single NHL game.

Now, not knowing what either Celebrini or Guenther could do in the NHL, I’d take Celebrini based on position, numbers and the harder pre professional league.

 

[Adam da bomb]

Team Canada is going to be very good with players like Celibrini, Guenther, Bedard.

 

[Eco]

Absolutely not. Wouldn’t trade Guenther for Celebrini, either. Guenther is going to be very very good.

This is a bold opinion there. lol

 

[jfhabs]

Typical bs post. Move along

As good as Guenter has been for the Yotes, Celibrini is another class of player, you simply can't seriously say you wouldn't make that trade

 

[SR]

As good as Guenter has been for the Yotes, Celibrini is another class of player, you simply can't seriously say you wouldn't make that trade

Really it comes down to a matter of opinions here. Read above, explains where im coming from.

 

[Xirik]

So... The Habs speed up their rebuild while Utah continues the rebuild forever.

Add Beck and Roy and it becomes closer but even then I don't know if Utah says yes.