Proposal: Mtl - car

[max3511]

Jeff skinner



Desharnais
Emelin
Hudon
Blackhawks 2nd 2017


Habs get a 2nd LW for multiple years but take a risk with his injury history.

Canes don't make it to cap floor. With Desharnais and Emelin, they get 2 player who can give time to younger player to develop and they don't have long term contract so they can decide what they want to do with them.

Hudon is a nice prospect who's NHL ready imo.

Click to read more...

 

[Rufus]

Quantity does not get you quality.

 

[Incubajerks]

hahahahaa

 

[StevenDean]

Yikes. Take two of those pieces away and add something of value then swap the 2nd for a 1st and maybe you have a shot.

 

[Nac Mac Feegle]

At least give the Canes one decent player in the trade. Bloody hell, that is awful.

 

[GTA]

We on the Habs board know that absolutely no one wants Desharnais and Emelin. This guys trade proposal is silly and doesn't reflect the vast majority of our fan base.

 

[GoldiFox]

Canes counter:

Paciorettty

For

Nestrasil
Stalberg
Tolchinsky
NYR's 2nd 2017

 

[Childish Gamsteeno]

This is....... not good for Carolina

 

[max3511]

Yikes. Take two of those pieces away and add something of value then swap the 2nd for a 1st and maybe you have a shot.

Common, you talk about a guy who played 2 complete season only, have been in possitive for +/- once, have done 60pts once?

 

[StevenDean]

Common, you talk about a guy who played 2 complete season only, have been in possitive for +/- once, have done 60pts once?

And you are talking about 3 mid to bottom line players and a 2nd for a 1LW. Get over yourself, if you want Skinner (and it sounds like you don't so why are you asking) offer something realistic. Crazy overvaluing fans.

 

[Bouboumaster]

Hudon is a great prospect, but c'mon now.

 

[dogbazinho]

Skinner is done sure why not. I finally get in on this!

 

[Whalermania]

Wow, that's beyond bad

 

[mcpw]

Eller Tinordi 2nd

 

[Halla]

hudon, late 2nd, and two cap dumps for a 30 goal threat?

lol

 

[BatVader]

Yikes. Take two of those pieces away and add something of value then swap the 2nd for a 1st and maybe you have a shot.

While the OP is a bad proposal, you are not getting this for a guy who is one concussion away from needing to be spoon fed the rest of his life, and who has shown he is injury prone.

 

[MinJaBen]

While the OP is a bad proposal, you are not getting this for a guy who is one concussion away from needing to be spoon fed the rest of his life, and who has shown he is injury prone.

He's actually missed very few games over his career, including the concussions. All of his concussions were of a fairly mild kind compared to other players you'd take in a heart beat: ie Crosby. We'll keep him, thanks.

 

[MakeTheGoalsLarger]

He's actually missed very few games over his career, including the concussions. All of his concussions were of a fairly mild kind compared to other players you'd take in a heart beat: ie Crosby. We'll keep him, thanks.

just checked his stats ... a bit shocking. This guys has a reputation for being injury prone.

 

[tarheelhockey]

Skinner is done sure why not. I finally get in on this!

TBH I think we're getting a steal here. Montreal gives up a great prospect AND three other players for a guy who literally may not play a game for them. If he gets caught with his head down during training camp, that's it. Then we're sitting pretty with 4 players to help re-stock our prospect pool with younger guys.

I'd have been willing to add a pick to make this happen, but that wasn't proposed so no takesies backsies.

 

[Blueline Bomber]

just checked his stats ... a bit shocking. This guys has a reputation for being injury prone.

And for a while, he was. But then he changed his style of play to leave him less exposed to big hits, and suddenly, he stopped getting rocked as much. But since he already developed that reputation, reality becomes an afterthought

 

[edguy]

More realistic for Canes would be something around Skinner and Gallagher. And Habs dont do it.
No fit here

 

[go4hockey]

Jeff skinner



Desharnais
Emelin
Hudon
Blackhawks 2nd 2017


Habs get a 2nd LW for multiple years but take a risk with his injury history.

Canes don't make it to cap floor. With Desharnais and Emelin, they get 2 player who can give time to younger player to develop and they don't have long term contract so they can decide what they want to do with them.

Hudon is a nice prospect who's NHL ready imo.

So a good player for spare parts. Yea that always works. . You would have to offer something of use.

 

[RodTheBawd]

Done. Tired of this soon-to-be vegetable dragging our offense down.

(alright boys, add this one to the drinking thread)

 

[Anton Babchuk]

Done. No takebacks.

 

[Roboturner913]

counter offer, Pacioretty for Brendan Woods, Valentin Zykov and a fourth rounder