Most interesting NHL player of all time?

It has to be Ken Dryden.

- Went to an Ivy League school after he was drafted and got a degree
- Won the Conn Smythe before he won the Calder
- Held out over a contract dispute when it was unheard of back then
- Took that time to get a Law degree
- Won 6 Cups overall and 4 in a row
- Wrote one of the best sports books ever written
- Could be prime minister of Canada one day lol

Who can beat that?

Dryden is actually one of the more boring guys in league history. To me he seems a bit aloof and just kind of dry. As if becoming a lawyer was so important...couldn't be bothered with something as pedestrian as playing in the NHL

not a player, but Harold Ballard was quite an interesting fellow
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Gilles Gratton and Tom Edur are some honourable mentions. The latter seems to have had some skills from the blueline scoring 55 points in 78 games in his last of two NHL seasons before retiring to the mental-mental institution named Jehovah's Witnesses. Does anyone know anything more about him since then?

Gilles Gratton, why exactly did he retire early? Just becouse he felt he had no power regarding what team to play for?
 
Gilles Gratton, why exactly did he retire early? Just becouse he felt he had no power regarding what team to play for?

Ya, you'd get a lotta bang for your buck with Gilles Gratton DY, seeing as how he has like Total Recall on all of his Past Lives going back to Biblical times. You wouldnt be having a conversation with just one person but multiple personalities. Get bored with OHL, WHA & NHL stories, you could ask him what it was like being a Soldier during the Spanish Inquisition or whatever. He'd gladly give you a first hand account. Talk your head off for hours about it. Very unusual individual. Ken Dryden figured Gratton really didnt much enjoy playing hockey after a certain stage in his pro career and by 24 after playing 41 games for New York in 77 (think that was the yr) the following season sent to New Haven and quit altogether after just 1 game.

Had oodles of talent but his head & heart just wasnt in it consistently enough. Could be a serious liability out there. In one game while with the Rangers, face~off in their own zone, Gilles there starts roaring & hissing like a Cat from behind his Tiger mask. His team mates cant keep it together, in hysterics, lose the face~off, tic-tac-toe pucks in the net behind Samba, King of the Jungle..... John Davidson was his roommate for awhile, Gilles a pretty spooky guy. Would just walk into the house, drop his coat on the floor, go sit down at the piano and start playing (quite brilliantly) heavy duty classical from the likes of Liszt & Chopin despite having never taken a lesson nor even practiced much. Right out of the blue. No doubt channeling one of his past lives.

Heres a brief article, great picture with Bobby Hull, gives you some idea as to his character: www.dennis-kane.com/tag/gilles-gratton/
 
  • Like
Reactions: Yozhik v tumane
igor the professor larionov

Him and Fetisov are right up there as guys I'd like to have an hour to talk to.

Tikhonov. Life under the Soviet system. Playing against Gretzky in Canada Cups. Fall of Communism. Coming to North America. Winning Stanley Cups. Involvement in Russian hockey at the manager level. Player agent. Fascinating stuff.
 
You should ask Igor what the trainer was injecting the players with in Soviet National team.In Igors book he said before every international tournament the trainer would put a needle in every player-but Igor said none of players knew what and were afraid to ask
 
Tikhonov. Life under the Soviet system. Playing against Gretzky in Canada Cups. Fall of Communism. Coming to North America. Winning Stanley Cups. Involvement in Russian hockey at the manager level. Player agent. Fascinating stuff.

Ya, quite a few Russians who it'd be very interesting to buttonhole & have conversations with. Kharlamov, Tretiak, Mogilny, Viktor Tikhonov & Anatoli Tarasov to name several.
 
now that is an obscure reference for a hockey forum

Sorry about that. ;)

The point was that I don't find Dryden's writing style (and life) terribly exciting, certainly not when compared to autobiographical books from other 'fields'. It's just that I haven't read many other hockey books, especially by NHL players, so I had to resort to that.

Tikhonov. Life under the Soviet system. Playing against Gretzky in Canada Cups. Fall of Communism. Coming to North America. Winning Stanley Cups. Involvement in Russian hockey at the manager level. Player agent. Fascinating stuff.

Well, there is the Swedish documentary on Tikhonov & Green Unit:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yuld5bKYLEQ

Although it may be of little use to those who don't speak Swedish (and/or Russian). And it was made about 10 years ago, when there was still a lot of bad blood between some of them; maybe that has changed a bit in recent years?
 
Although I find the current Dryden boring and long-winded, I think it should be stated that his first book, The Game, was written as a hockey player who was highly educated. It is far more readable and interesting than anything else he's published written as an intellectual who was a former hockey player.
 
First guy I thought of was Brian Spencer

Ya. That name came to mind though not really as one that invokes "gee, betcha he'd be an interesting guy"?..... I'm afraid I dont find tragic characters all that absorbing nor interesting. Morbid, sad. :(
 
I agree with you Killion but have you ever watched the movie on cbc and if you did was it 100 percent factual.
 
I agree with you Killion but have you ever watched the movie on cbc and if you did was it 100 percent factual.

Ya, I saw the movie a couple of times but that was several years ago and it wasnt bad, but not great either. Read the book by Martin O'Malley which was brilliant; The Life & Times of Spinner Spencer. That was certainly pretty jarring. Seriously tragic story and hockey has many of them. Real Chevrefils, Doug Harvey, Derek Sanderson, John Kordic, Bob Probert etc.
 

Definity a candidate along with such "characters" as Eddie Shack, Sean Avery and Alex Ovechkin.

Some of the early day guys like psycho Sprague Cleghorn and One-Eyed Frank McGee and arguably hockey's all-time greatest athlete (and eventual MP) Lionel Conacher should also get a vote....

But my candidate is "Terrible" Ted Lindsay... a star player who never backed down from a fight, be it with the opponents, management, the NHL or the HHoF.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Boxscore
Wasn't sure where to put this but came across it while researching something else, otherwise known as not doing my hunny do list my wife gave me, so I'll share it here.

This is an interesting story about Gary "Suitcase" Smith who was a character goalie, hell I thought all goalies were crazy back then, for my childhood Vancouver canucks.

 
I think Len Barrie is interesting. My dad was a season ticket holder in Lethbridge when the Hurricanes came to Lethbridge. Neither I nor my father have any recollection of Barrie playing for Victoria when they played Lethbridge. Then as an overager ends up in Kamloops and has one of the best seasons in WHL history. Kamloops played Lethbridge in the league finals and dominated.

I think due to conditioning issues he doesn’t materialize into a NHL’er. He plays one NHL season in 94 and a smattering of games and ends up out of the league as a mid level IHL’er and European league player for 5-6 years. When he is over 30 he ends up getting a chance and plays 2 full NHL seasons which strikes me as very odd and unusual. Then despite not having made any real NHL money ends up running a huge development in BC and part owner of the Tampa Bay Lightning.

This ends being a house of cards and it all ends up in bankruptcy including losing his 10 million dollar house. Despite many allegations he is never charged with a crime.

It is unclear to me how he got his start and ended up in that much control of that much money. Somewhere between 10’s and 100’s of millions.

On top of that he has a son (Tyson) who continues to play in the NHL.
 
Matt Barnaby was an interesting specimen
Screenshot_20250330_162006_Google.jpg
 

Ad

Ad