Torts plays defense shield wall hockey. He hasn't adapted to the salary cap era very well. He has changed his approach when communicating with players, but not his overall deployment style.
I want nothing to do with defense first, whether it's Laxdal, Torts, or Nelson if he intends to coach that way. I want someone who worships at the altar of the Corsi gods. Someone who presses, involves all five guys, and plays active defense.
Entertaining hockey that has guys improving should be the order of the day.
100% agree with
@XX on this one. May never happen again so maybe worth mentioning...
But to be clear
@XX didn't you go out of your way to belittle / personally attack me after I brought up Kessel's positive relative Corsi / Fenwick when you were trying to argue he was worse than a replacement AHLer...? *shrug*
Imo one of the main problems with Tocchet (out of many) is that he was trying to coach a style that our team had no business playing. By that I mean Chayka made us a small, skilled team that also happened to be soft. So, why in the world would a coach with a small, soft, decently skilled team insist on coaching a system that relied on being greasy / winning puck battles in the offensive zone? Obvi easier to armchair quarterback but our system made no sense for the players we have (arguable if the system would have made sense anyway, I am not touching that).
Anyway, our core forwards are not great at defense and they are not heavy -- Schmaltz, Keller, Kessel etc... I mean, we have one of the smaller teams in the whole league and they are not better than other teams at defense -- we once had good defensive forwards -- but Richardson and Stepan are both gone now (yes, I know the boards generally hates them but they were both well above average defensively compared to other NHL centers). So imo a defensive coach makes no sense because we don't have the personnel for them.
Either way, we need a coach who can mentor and grow our young players. Imo that's by far the most important thing, it's not even close. For better or worse we're stuck with guys like Keller and Schmaltz for the medium to long term, the only way we get good in the next 5 years-ish is if they actually become a better than average NHL first liners in terms of scoring