Toggle sidebar

Proposal: Montreal - Florida

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
Mark Kandy

Mark Kandy

Habcoolic
Jul 22, 2014
1,519
101
Montreal
:habs

Jonathan Huberdeau


:panthers

Mikhail Sergachev
2017 1st Round Pick (Lottery protected, becomes 2018 1st Round Pick if top5)
Sven Andrighetto



Montreal really need a left winger on their top6 and Huberdeau would be a perfect fit. That price is kind of steep but I think it would get us closer to the contender tag.

Thoughts?
Click to read more...
 
Huberdeau is pretty much the vanguard of their core along with Barkov, and Montreal _really_ needs their top flight D prospects. Florida will have to console themselves with their obscenely good defensive core.
 
Kid Icarus said:
To the Panthers:

Pacioretty

To Montreal:

2017 first
Logan Shaw
Juho Lammikko
Click to expand...

^ looool so far away from ops-proposal. :laugh: c'mon dude.

it's not terrible imo. panthers pass since they're in win-now-mode and would be foolish to send one of their best young players to a rival within the division for pick/prospects.
 
spacemanatee said:
^ looool so far away from ops-proposal. :laugh: c'mon dude.

it's not terrible imo. panthers pass since they're in win-now-mode and would be foolish to send one of their best young players to a rival within the division for pick/prospects.
Click to expand...

You're right. I forgot to lottery protect the Panthers 1st.
 
spacemanatee said:
;)
but seriously, how is shaw or lammikko even close to sergachev?
Click to expand...

Not to mention that Pacioretty is better at everything except the talent of being young.

The value favours the Panthers slightly, but not enough for them to drastically alter their team.
 
Wether the value is there is irrelevant, as this offer doesn't take Florida's needs into considération.

For your fantasy league, it works... but not fot the NHL
 
value is there but Flordia isn't looking for futures.

Habs will have a completion with Andrighetto and Lehkonen at camp. If one of them win the spot great, otherwise Shaw will be #2 LW and Habs will upgrade at the deadline.
 
The thing is Florida doesn't have needs in terms of players or prospects. They just need to mature a bit and they will be there.
 
Our LW depth would take a serious blow with losing Huberdeau and Crouse in one week. A major reason we unloaded Bolland would probably be to re-sign Huberdeau this upcoming off-season.

Jokinen becomes our 1st line winger, McCann becomes our 2nd line winger. I don't like it at all.

The value is close but if I were trading Hubderdeau, futures would not be the return I take. No thank you to the offer.

Why not go after JVR? He'd be a little cheaper since he's a UFA at the end of his deal.
 
This is a realy good proposal, but as an habs fan, I just dont want to ruin our prospect bank like we did in the Gainey era. Remember you MB has already traded almost all our 2nd round pick. We need young quality players in the process
 
Kid Icarus said:
To the Panthers:

Pacioretty

To Montreal:

2017 first
Logan Shaw
Juho Lammikko
Click to expand...

LOL yeah Juho Lammikko and Mikhail Sergachev are two comparable prospects! :help:

And Andrighetto had 17 points in 44 games (0.39 PPG) playing 13 minutes a game and almost half the games on the 4th line... he is a better player than Logan Shaw, no doubt.
 
bleuetbio said:
This is a realy good proposal, but as an habs fan, I just dont want to ruin our prospect bank like we did in the Gainey era. Remember you MB has already traded almost all our 2nd round pick. We need young quality players in the process
Click to expand...

I agree, but at the same time I think our window will be closing in 2-3-4 seasons so I'd prefer to all-in right now.
 
Kobe Armstrong said:
lol they really don't know hockey in Florida, huh :laugh:

Not even close to the OP's proposal, buddy
Click to expand...

Mark Kandy said:
LOL yeah Juho Lammikko and Mikhail Sergachev are two comparable prospects! :help:

And Andrighetto had 17 points in 44 games (0.39 PPG) playing 13 minutes a game and almost half the games on the 4th line... he is a better player than Logan Shaw, no doubt.
Click to expand...

I take it you guys have never seen the response to a bad offer in the OP with a much worse counter offer comment.


As for the trade offer, it's bad.
 
Dabeast said:
I take it you guys have never seen the response to a bad offer in the OP with a much worse counter offer comment.


As for the trade offer, it's bad.
Click to expand...

I understand the Panthers have no intention to trade Huberdeau, but that doesn't make the offer a bad one. I mean, Sergachev is a beast and just got draft 9th overall, plus a 2017 1st Round Pick, plus Andrighetto who will be playing on our top6 this season and will probably be able to put 40-45 points on the board.

Maybe it's not what you would be looking to get back for Huberdeau, but value-wise, I don't think it's bad.
 
Mark Kandy said:
I agree, but at the same time I think our window will be closing in 2-3-4 seasons so I'd prefer to all-in right now.
Click to expand...

Sorry buddy, but I dont think you got it right! On your own window, Cheap labors become crucial and Sergachev + Ghetto + next 1st draft pick at ELC would be a better 6M$ investment than a Huberdeau at 6M$ alone

Maybe you waste 2 years of the window, but you'll need players like this in the process. Im also a Hawks a fan and we couldnt win it all with just Hossa, Kane, Toews, Keith and Crawford on the team.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom