Proposal: Monahan / Domi

[Johnny Hoxville]

Flame away, who says no?

Click to read more...

 

[Voight]

Calgary... I get Monahan's point production has gone down significantly the last 3 years but he has a better track record than Domi

 

[WhiskeyYerTheDevils]

Columbus says no. Monahan is a negative value asset and Domi is the better player.

 

[The Jones Zone]

CBJ is looking to retain max and get picks for Domi likely

Monahan likely can, and would void this deal (MNT clause)

it's a triple no go

 

[Fro]

Won't lie, I'd love to see SM in Columbus...so I'd be one board with some sort of pick involved as an insurance on Monahan form..but forget what is allowed and not

 

[Ledge And Dairy]

He wont be traded until the offseason. By then Domi will be gone. I would look to dp something around Bemstrom or Foudy from CBJ

 

[Junohockeyfan]

Monahan is a cap dump. Domi is a rental. You do the math!

 

[WhiskeyYerTheDevils]

He wont be traded until the offseason. By then Domi will be gone. I would look to dp something around Bemstrom or Foudy from CBJ

You think a team is going to give assets for Monahan?

Oof.

 

[Cowumbus]

As a CBJ fan I think that the Flames would say no, but I would like Monahan in Cbus.

 

[seanlinden]

Honestly... I'll give the OP some points for creativity.

I think Columbus would say no... but don't think it would be a "hard" no. If the deal was, say, Monahan + a 3rd for Domi... I'd imagine that the Jackets say yes.

Ultimately, while Monahan seems to be overpaid, it's important to remember that this is a guy who has scored 82 points in a season, and should be in the prime of his career at 27 years old. Columbus is also fairly thin with respect to talent in the middle of the ice. It's a reasonably low-risk; high-reward gamble if they can rehabilitate him somewhat.

 

[majormajor]

Honestly... I'll give the OP some points for creativity.

I think Columbus would say no... but don't think it would be a "hard" no. If the deal was, say, Monahan + a 3rd for Domi... I'd imagine that the Jackets say yes.

Ultimately, while Monahan seems to be overpaid, it's important to remember that this is a guy who has scored 82 points in a season, and should be in the prime of his career at 27 years old. Columbus is also fairly thin with respect to talent in the middle of the ice. It's a reasonably low-risk; high-reward gamble if they can rehabilitate him somewhat.

I don't think a 3rd will sway things one way or the other. You either think Monahan is a positive asset at $6.375 million next year or you think he's a negative at that hit.

Personally it's been nice to see him find some use this year but he's still nowhere near a 6 million dollar player. Calgary would have to pay Columbus a significant price to take on his contract (like 1st or Pelletier or something).

 

[WhiskeyYerTheDevils]

Honestly... I'll give the OP some points for creativity.

I think Columbus would say no... but don't think it would be a "hard" no. If the deal was, say, Monahan + a 3rd for Domi... I'd imagine that the Jackets say yes.

Ultimately, while Monahan seems to be overpaid, it's important to remember that this is a guy who has scored 82 points in a season, and should be in the prime of his career at 27 years old. Columbus is also fairly thin with respect to talent in the middle of the ice. It's a reasonably low-risk; high-reward gamble if they can rehabilitate him somewhat.

Unless they have a guy like Gaudreau, I wouldn't expect even 40 points from Monahan.

 

[North Man]

Unless they have a guy like Gaudreau, I wouldn't expect even 40 points from Monahan.

Bro we get it, you hate Sean Monahan. Pipe down already.

 

[seanlinden]

I don't think a 3rd will sway things one way or the other. You either think Monahan is a positive asset at $6.375 million next year or you think he's a negative at that hit.

Personally it's been nice to see him find some use this year but he's still nowhere near a 6 million dollar player. Calgary would have to pay Columbus a significant price to take on his contract (like 1st or Pelletier or something).

I think a team like Columbus would view him as a positive asset, but one that carries such a great risk of failing to be that, that you don't really want to give up anything of value for.

Domi, in my view, has some value as a rental (especially at 50% retained). I think he'd probably get a 2nd round pick clear, or a 3rd + a decent prospect. Columbus isn't want to forgo all of that to take the gamble on Monahan, but if you can get most / some of the value out of Domi, and get Monahan's upside, I think it makes a bit of sense.

 

[seanlinden]

Unless they have a guy like Gaudreau, I wouldn't expect even 40 points from Monahan.

They've got Laine & Voracek.

 

[WhiskeyYerTheDevils]

Bro we get it, you hate Sean Monahan. Pipe down already.

I don't hate Monahan.

But it does seem like you hate the truth.

 

[WhiskeyYerTheDevils]

They've got Laine & Voracek.

Probably not going to do it. You'd probably be wise to keep Monahan away from your top wingers like Calgary has learned.

He can be an effective bumper guy on the PP but he's pretty much a 4C at 5v5.

 

[Bouboumaster]

Honestly, if I'm Calgary, I'd might pull the trigger

It's a lateral move (they have different flaws but both of them are flawed player) but Domi's contract is done this summer.
That's a good way to get out of the Monahan contract

 

[DingDongCharlie]

Domi is a pending ufa that will easily return a 2nd + lesser asset if moved (especially as someone mentioned 50% retained)

Monahan is a cap dump at his current hit. If anyone offered a 2nd + prospect for Monahan you are also taking a dump back to balance the cap. Nobody would offer what Columbus will get for a rental Domi and eat Monahan’s full 6+ million cap hit.

 

[majormajor]

I think a team like Columbus would view him as a positive asset, but one that carries such a great risk of failing to be that, that you don't really want to give up anything of value for.

Domi, in my view, has some value as a rental (especially at 50% retained). I think he'd probably get a 2nd round pick clear, or a 3rd + a decent prospect. Columbus isn't want to forgo all of that to take the gamble on Monahan, but if you can get most / some of the value out of Domi, and get Monahan's upside, I think it makes a bit of sense.

They have better uses of $6m. Monahan is a dump with little upside. Closer to Lucic value.

 

[DFF]

Flame away, who says no?

Apparently Brad Treliving

 

[Viqsi]

There's a part of me that would love to believe Monahan can be rehabbed.

Then the rest of me recognizes how heavy that contract is, how poor his play has been for multiple years, and how even when he was good he was primarily a finisher rather than a playmaker (the opposite of what we need).

 

[TheDawnOfANewTage]

There's a part of me that would love to believe Monahan can be rehabbed.

Then the rest of me recognizes how heavy that contract is, how poor his play has been for multiple years, and how even when he was good he was primarily a finisher rather than a playmaker (the opposite of what we need).

He was part of a lotta Eichel trade rumors, and I’d have been so pissed had that actually happened. Dude is declining hard, just felt like he’d be trash without the right support- closing in on a turris sorta level of play.

That said, I don’t think I make that exchange if I’m either side. Monahan ain’t great, but he plays the flames style as far as I know. Domi is more boom or bust, just feels like a risk getting him on board before the postseason.

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

Doubtful either team would make that trade.

 

[zar]

Not a chance in hell CBJ bites on that.

Monahan is a plug… he’s done… he has another year left at over $6m cap hit.

Ever since coming back from injury 2 years ago, he is one of the worst values in the league.

Let this soak in for awhile Sean Monahan is -14 on a team that has a +63 goal differential.