It’s an interesting take. Not one that I have really considered, but what I see out there is a guy who has no confidence right now.
He is the king of overpassing, and when he really gets in trouble is when he doesn’t have the confidence that he can finish the play himself. He’d rather deflect the responsibility of finishing the play because he’s doubtful of his own ability to do so. He tried again to make the perfect pass to Kreider on the PP and it failed miserably. He should’ve just taken the shot there. In my opinion he’s more likely to score than he is to get that pass through. Especially since we just scored that way. The prior game. It takes a special talent to beat teams the same way over and over and over again. Defenses adapt. the only players that can ever do this are generational, and that’s not Mika.
I haven’t really seen a physical decline, he seems to be moving just as fine as he ever did. I really think it’s a confidence issue. He knows he faced criticism for his performance last year, and it’s possible that the issue is compounding.
All that being said, I don’t know how to fix this. We can’t just write him off. He’s likely better than anyone else out there that’s available. You can point to the Zib/Brassard trade and say do it again, but the reality is that we got extremely lucky there.
He probably deserves a demotion or a healthy scratch, but that could just exacerbate the issue. We really need him to get going if we’re gonna have any shot at a cup