Matvei Michkov vs. Ivan Demidov; who will be better?

Who will be better?


  • Total voters
    554
Status
Not open for further replies.
Didn’t see the post but not sure id go that far . He’s a huge talent but what rookies have gone ppg over the past decade ? Mcdavid obviously ( half year but still ) , not sure how old Panarin was or whether he fits the criteria . I’m sure I’m missing someone obvious. Maybe Barzal ? I remember him having a great year then kinda plateauing
Very few did. Ovechkin also did it. Even a 60 points season would be a huge accomplishment for a 19 years old. Again, not many can say they had 60+ points season before they turn 20
 
I don’t think Michkov will go ppg his rookie year, but also I wouldn’t be completely flabbergasted if he did. I think the Vegas over/under or whatever is at like 48 points, I’d be shocked if he doesn’t eclipse that, he’ll be on PP1 and play with some decent players, health will be a factor, but he’s built like a fire hydrant we’ll see. Most of my confidence not only comes from his talent level but just that he’s been playing against grown men for years, the adjustment is going to be a bit quicker for him vice other high level talents coming out of juniors making the jump right to the NHL. I’m very curious to see this Calder race with Celebrini.
 
I don’t think Michkov will go ppg his rookie year, but also I wouldn’t be completely flabbergasted if he did. I think the Vegas over/under or whatever is at like 48 points, I’d be shocked if he doesn’t eclipse that, he’ll be on PP1 and play with some decent players, health will be a factor, but he’s built like a fire hydrant we’ll see. Most of my confidence not only comes from his talent level but just that he’s been playing against grown men for years, the adjustment is going to be a bit quicker for him vice other high level talents coming out of juniors making the jump right to the NHL. I’m very curious to see this Calder race with Celebrini.
Agreed . The Sharks are starting to accumulate a wealth of talent . Smith and Celebrini down the middle could be Studly .
 
This doesnt make much sense, you guys haven't even had a player putting up numbers like a Giroux for how long? And I'm here to say Giroux is nowhere near the talent Michkov is at the same age and I tracked him closely way before the NHL, help me to understand your logic.
My logic is that I am a Flyers fan. I have been one since the early 80s. The Flyers have bad things happen to them or they just do dumb things. This is how it works for them. Claude Giroux is the outlier. he was able to achieve in spite of the Flyers curse. I have long lists of issues with the Flyers if you would like me to list my 40-plus year grievances.

The Flyers are notoriously bad at developing prospects. Typically the prospects are worse than advertised or at best become what they were supposed to. Maybe you could argue that Konecny is better than he was suppsoed to be, but he is basically as good as his upside was advertised. For a team that had the number 1 ranked prospect pool by THN a few years ago, this team has sure underachieved.
 
My logic is that I am a Flyers fan. I have been one since the early 80s. The Flyers have bad things happen to them or they just do dumb things. This is how it works for them. Claude Giroux is the outlier. he was able to achieve in spite of the Flyers curse. I have long lists of issues with the Flyers if you would like me to list my 40-plus year grievances.

The Flyers are notoriously bad at developing prospects. Typically the prospects are worse than advertised or at best become what they were supposed to. Maybe you could argue that Konecny is better than he was suppsoed to be, but he is basically as good as his upside was advertised. For a team that had the number 1 ranked prospect pool by THN a few years ago, this team has sure underachieved.

I get it, and I don't question your experience and frustration with the Flyers and their development issues. My quarrel is that Michkov is so good how do you mess him up? The guy is simply one of the best prospects that I've watched outside the generational guys, I just think he hits irregardless of anything the Flyers do, I think the right question is now is will they surround him with the right pieces. I'm praying Briere can figure it out, but it's unlikely since the teams front office is a bunch of dinosaurs.
 
I get it, and I don't question your experience and frustration with the Flyers and their development issues. My quarrel is that Michkov is so good how do you mess him up? The guy is simply one of the best prospects that I've watched outside the generational guys, I just think he hits irregardless of anything the Flyers do, I think the right question is now is will they surround him with the right pieces. I'm praying Briere can figure it out, but it's unlikely since the teams front office is a bunch of dinosaurs.
I just anticipate issues - for example, let's say Michkov gets 40 points in his first season. The Flyers fans are expecting this guy to get like 80, which is unreasonable. The next year he gets 60, and then maybe 70. The Flyer fans are expecting him to be at least a ppg player. At this point Flyer fans get angry with the lack of point production and begin to boo him, which is something Flyers fans do. He doesn't like the treatment and refuses to sign a new contract and demands a trade.

Or, he ends up having injury issues which the Flyers have had to deal with. A short list includes Lindbergh who died in a car crash after winning the Vezina, and then the likes of Lindros, Primeau, and Pronger, who all had to retire because of concussions, and then Nolan Patrick having migraines.

The basic mantra at this point is that something is bound to happen to mess this up.
 
A few weeks ago I would have said Michkov…but Demidov is blowing my mind with what he’s doing in the KHL…a danger every shift, what a player.

This could very well be Makin/Ovechkin 2.0 and I’m not even kidding.
Now imagine if they were both 6"3 monsters like those two freaks. Game has changed so it doesn't matter much but man we were lucky to get Geno and Ovi at the same time in the same decade
 
  • Like
Reactions: waitin425
A few weeks ago I would have said Michkov…but Demidov is blowing my mind with what he’s doing in the KHL…a danger every shift, what a player.

This could very well be Makin/Ovechkin 2.0 and I’m not even kidding.
I haven't missed a SKA game.

Demidov has looked very mid outside of one game vs a brutal team.. he's been putrid defensively, a giveaway machine and scored 2 points in 7 games with 15 MIN ATOI without the Sochi game.

Michkov on the other hand is DOMINATING NHL competition.

2G 3A 5P in 3 games played
 
  • Haha
Reactions: The Gr8 Dane
I haven't missed a SKA game.

Demidov has looked very mid outside of one game vs a brutal team.. he's been putrid defensively, a giveaway machine and scored 2 points in 7 games with 15 MIN ATOI without the Sochi game.

Michkov on the other hand is DOMINATING NHL competition.

2G 3A 5P in 3 games played
You’re so full of shit it’s actually crazy lmao
 
Demidov
Mitchkov

Carlsson

Fantilli
In reality

Michkov

Fantilli

Carlsson


Demidov

You’re so full of shit it’s actually crazy lmao
Just stating facts.

Give me his stat line without the Sochi game, it's exactly what I said it is.

He has 9 giveaways in those 7 games as well, that's brutal

The facts hurt your feelings, that isn't my problem. He's going to need time adjusting to a real league after playing very low level MHL
 
I haven't missed a SKA game.

Demidov has looked very mid outside of one game vs a brutal team.. he's been putrid defensively, a giveaway machine and scored 2 points in 7 games with 15 MIN ATOI without the Sochi game.

Michkov on the other hand is DOMINATING NHL competition.

2G 3A 5P in 3 games played
vllxi1I.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: SlafySZN
Give me his stat line without the Sochi game, it's exactly what I said it is.

He has 9 giveaways in those 7 games as well, that's brutal

The facts hurt your feelings, that isn't my problem. He's going to need time adjusting to a real league after playing very low level MHL
The fact is you don’t actually watch games and it’s very obvious

Which teams is he allowed to score against for it to count btw? Can we get your list now so we can know whether he sucks or not?
 
Dude :laugh::laugh::laugh::laugh: Its actually hilarious
Give me his stat line without Sochi game please, go.

You're wrong

Next

The fact is you don’t actually watch games and it’s very obvious

Which teams is he allowed to score against for it to count btw? Can we get your list now so we can know whether he sucks or not?
You're mad that I'm stating facts and your only rebuttal is that I'm not watching the games? I literally have a breakdown of every shift of every SKA game on my Twitter you nerd.

Be mad at the facts, not me.

He can score on whatever team he want, he's been very mid outside of one game.

Debate with a wall
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad