Kamiccolo
Truly wonderful, the mind of a child is.
I doubt he takes less than Eichel when he's proven to be more effective and score more proficiently. Why should he? Just out of the goodness of his heart? Players who take discounts to win are usually in their mid to late 30s, as hangers on trying for that one last run to get a Cup ring. Doubt it happens with Matthews. Also, when those Pens deals you described were signed they were a much bigger percentage of the cap than they are today (obviously because of the cap rising year after year). I mean, MAYBE he takes a discount but I think it would naive to count or bank on it.
If he has another 40 goal season and scores at a point per game then he has every right to ask for 11m or so based on other precedents.
Like I said, many many players have taken discounts, and not just in their 30's. So I am struggling to understand why it's only Leaf players who would be unwilling to take a discount to ice a competitive team?