Youtube: Matt Rempe vs Dylan McIlrath

trick9

Registered User
Jun 2, 2013
12,521
5,627
McIlrath is quickly climbing the ladder of NHL heavies.

He should've started at the top. He's been the king of the AHL for years already and there's better fighters down there who can't actually play hockey.

Seems like Rempe was ducking him for a reason.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bryanbryoil

CharasLazyWrister

Registered User
Sep 8, 2008
24,878
22,067
Northborough, MA
Rempe is just not a very good figher.

I’m wondering when people are going to come around to the reality of the player and not the “idea” of the player.

I mean, I wouldn’t say he’s a bad fighter. But relative to his height, he’s not nearly the monster he’s made out to be. He’s also a bad hockey player.
 

bov

Registered User
Nov 13, 2010
7,329
3,495
He should've started at the top. He's been the king of the AHL for years already and there's better fighters down there who can't actually play hockey.

Seems like Rempe was ducking him for a reason.
He's fought him twice, went with Reaves, MacDermid, Deslauriers...kid isn't ducking anybody.

Not much of a fight, McIlrath is one of the top fighters in pro hockey anyway so there's no shame in losing that one.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DaaaaB's

Cams

Registered User
May 27, 2008
1,498
610
Windsor, ON
Wasn't McIlrath mostly drafted as high as he was (10th OA) because of his junior fighting prowess? Reputation as toughest guy in the CHL in his draft year? Looking at that draft, there wasn't much toughness selected - I do believe he had a fight with Alex Petrovic at the CHL prospects game here in Windsor that year.
 

bov

Registered User
Nov 13, 2010
7,329
3,495
If you look at almost all of the top "heavyweights" now, it took them YEARS at the pro level to hang with the big boys at the top of the heap. Someone like Xhekaj is a pretty rare exception. Rempe is 22 and hasn't even grown into his body yet, pretty crazy to see the criticism when he's taking on these killers.
 

stephenball

Registered User
Jan 7, 2018
462
893
This is just a case of an experienced fighter going up against a guy who is just big and brave. McIlrath knew he could just feed him those left jabs without losing hold of him.
 

DaaaaB's

Registered User
Apr 24, 2004
8,630
2,207
If you look at almost all of the top "heavyweights" now, it took them YEARS at the pro level to hang with the big boys at the top of the heap. Someone like Xhekaj is a pretty rare exception. Rempe is 22 and hasn't even grown into his body yet, pretty crazy to see the criticism when he's taking on these killers.
Yeah anyone who can hold their own against Deslauriers isn't a bad fighter. People should go back and watch some of John Scott's early fights. Rempe will never be as good at fighting as Scott became but he'll get better.

I don't agree about Xhekaj though, he hasn't fought many top heavyweights and has struggled with the ones he did.
 

bov

Registered User
Nov 13, 2010
7,329
3,495
Yeah anyone who can hold their own against Deslauriers isn't a bad fighter. People should go back and watch some of John Scott's early fights. Rempe will never be as good at fighting as Scott became but he'll get better.

I don't agree about Xhekaj though, he hasn't fought many top heavyweights and has struggled with the ones he did.
I think he can hang with most of them already, but wouldn't shock me if he gets exposed too. I guess he didn't look so great against Johnston or Deslauriers now that I watch it again.
 

Your Boy Troy

Registered User
Sep 19, 2013
2,857
792
Brampton, Ontario
Rempe once again gets a bad grab right at the middle of McIlrath's collar. If he's going to be more cautious and technical, then he needs to grab around the far side shoulder area, where he can get a better restraint of that throwing arm.
 

TimeZone

Make the pick
Sep 15, 2008
20,286
9,017
Lost
I'm sure you'd lay a beating on him .

If I were a goon paid millions of dollars to throw punches and played in the NHL, most likely.

Dude is batting about .200 right now.

It's not like the 6'7 guy blocking jabs with his face is killing it with technique in there, this guy would be on life support by now if he were fighting the enforcers of 20 years ago with his inability to utilize range or simply showcase any kind of even below average defense.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad