I felt exactly the same about O-dog when he started with Hayes and Noodles. I think it is a bit natural for former players to get a bit overaggressive and overconfident on some subjects, probably because it hits close to home.
I think O'Sullivan is providing some of the best parts of Leafs Lunch at the moment. He is unpolished, sure. Sometimes he has long awkward pauses. But I totally agree with you, he has potential.
Never a big fan of Matt Cauz. I thought that Bob Mackowycz was the worst of the worst, though. The guy tore his own co-hosts down all the time. I get it is a cut-throat business, but he was just a jerk.
Am I the only one who is OK with Naylor and Landsberg?