The way I see it, the claims of the death of our prospect pool have been greatly exaggerated. I'm (perhaps wishfully?) reminded of the sentiment around the end of the Quinn days when it was in vogue to completely shit on our pool because of everything we traded away, then we went on graduate of tonne of solid complementary type players drafted from that 2000-2004 window. Then the 2006 draft was just ridiculously efficient.
Just looking superficially
Tier 1- the First Rounders
Cowan is Cowan. Solid A- prospect with top 6 upside and a pretty high floor
Danford- will be underrated until the day he "surprises" and steals a spot with the Leafs. He may not reach his upside, but that upside as a Tanev/Carlo type is there nonetheless
Tier 2A- The Marlies
Quillan- reminds me so much of Moore, but bigger and a C. Tenacious, NHL level 190 foot game from almost day 1 but needed an adjustment period for the last 10 feet (offensively) to click. If he doesn't start with the Leafs next year, he finishes
Villeneuve- good size, decent mobility. Seems to have grown into an all-situations top pairing D at the AHL level, I hope he's given a chance in camp next year
Tier2B- The Marlies (goaltender editions)
Hildeby and AA- both have had up and down years, both have shown flashes. Either could end up a starter, both could end up back in Europe pretty quick.
Tier 3- the quiet stud
Chadwick- not enough is written about the guy. Maybe the leaf prospect followers association is collectively once bitten/twice shy because of Andrew Neilsen, and maybe he is another Neilsen, but... 6'4 dman with 109 points in 132 regular season games post draft. Solid defensively. Skating not a minus. Recognized as the top defenseman in the WHL's Eastern conference over two highly regarded 1st rounders in Yakemchuk and Molendyk. If he had better draft day pedigree (or we reached on him) and was picked in the top 90 we would be getting HYPED.
Tier 4- 4thline's favorites
McCue- stupid goal scoring numbers this season to go with his pestiness and work ethic. Curious to see where he plays next season.
Mayes- quietly took a huge step in both gameplay and production. Not just a 7th round thug, there's something to watch there
Johansson- why not. What's not to love about a skinny, great skating OFD that likes to play violent. If he can add the mass to translate his game against men...
Valis, Haymes- free wallets baby, and young enough to have some serious development in front of them