Because I'm not part of the mind hive? I'm not saying because I am a defenseman and have played 40+ years my opinion should be valued more than others, but I do watch everything the D do with particular interest, and since the Stan hate gang really started rallying the troops I've been watching him and his bottom 5 peers with a keener eye to try to figure out where these guys slot in in my mind.
I don't mind Miller but I don't particularly love his passing or exits - he has zero offensive ability, and he doesn't seem particularly composed with the puck.
I think he's fine as a 7 but that's it.
To be fair, any of our current bottom 5 guys are probably close to even when you add up their positives and subtract their negatives. The only one that might be a bit above them is Fleury, who has an all round solid game, and has good speed and ability to carry the puck out of the zone and through the neutral zone (though he isn't particularily good at offensive blueline work and getting quality shots through.
Stanley:
- Positives: Strong exit passes, composure in his zone, good offensive shot selection, some offensive prowess.
- Negatives: Doesn't use his size as well as he could (winning board battles, net front box out, hit timing). Is below average in agility, particularly when pivoting. Seems to struggle with timing on the rush (when to turn).
Heinola:
- Positives: Shows flashes of offensive prowess (agility, stickhandling). Solid exit passes, with the odd great spring pass.
- Negatives: Panics with the puck under pressure, loses most board battles, ineffective net front, not a lot generated from the point (yet).
Coghlan:
- Positives: Good speed and offensive instincts, shows ability to skate the puck out of the zone. Decent decision making with the puck in our zone (usually).
- Negatives: Not great at breaking pressure in our zone, not particularly strong.
Miller:
- Positives: Usually pretty reliable, keeps things simple, has a cannon, is a RD.
- Negatives: Doesn't use his shot enough, gets the yips in our zone, isn't offensively capable.