A1LeafNation
Good, is simply not good enough!
- Oct 17, 2010
- 27,934
- 18,185
Was he mentioned in Shanahans dissertation of playoff injuries?What makes you say that?
Was he mentioned in Shanahans dissertation of playoff injuries?What makes you say that?
Found em!
Was he mentioned in Shanahans dissertation of playoff injuries?
I was referring to Shanahan, but Marner’s gotta go too, no matter how butt hurt some here will be……….To Marner or Shanny or both?
Is the conference over? have they made any moves yet?
No way they "strip" him of the captaincy. However, they could mutually agree that it's time to pass the torch or WE, nothing wrong with that. But I also agree that I'm not sure Matthews is the ideal "captain type" so there is that. If it was me, I'd try to signs Domi long term and make him the captin, I think he'd be great! But most likely JT will be captain for at least one more year, JMHO.i've said this so many times.
the only team I can think of in the last 20 years who actually stripped someone of their Captaincy was San Jose and they did it three times. Joe Thornton to Patty Marleau, to the other one. (sorry my memory isn't as good). the other Joe. and that caused drama. people wanna Strip Tavares of his captaincy - like that wouldn't be drama and then when i brought it up it's like well leadership needs to be people who produce. like.. okay?
and again I don't personally believe that Matthews is the best choice to be the captain regardless of his on ice production.
I liked a lot of the answers, but the time for talking is done. Now let's see what they do about it.
Is this a joke? No offence, but it's hard to tell with you sometimes if you're serious or just talking nonsense ...Is the conference over? have they made any moves yet?
I'm one who doesn't love BT, but he'll be fine. He'll make mistakes (as he already has), but I think he'll get some things right (as he also already has). I don't love that we're settling for fine, but it also might be good enough given the starting point he has. It's a ridiculously good team, better than the one he built in Calgary, so if he does/can trade someone like Marner, he should get a really good return. And he's not going to humiliate anyone (that's a good thing), that's not his style. Anything he does will be with respect to the players involved and it'll be as quiet as it can be (also a good thing).Do Leaf fans have trust Treliving to make good/acceptable trades? Also in hiring a new head coach? There is no Darryl Sutter this time.
Because they need a hard cap to support hockey in Arizona. Hey, wait....I don’t understand why teams can’t get retention on their own players.
It’s a dumb, dumb imbalance in the CBA
Nonsense. No GM pulls off that trade or even attempts it with a month on the job and a month to get it done.
Thank you brother. Well documented
I have a call at 1pm. You free? need someone to take down detailed minutes
I don't care what you think of the team, if JT is here (and that's likely), you're probably not going to take the captaincy away from him, right? I honestly don't even know the reason you would. Yes, he's a bit of a robot (understatement), but no one is questioning his work ethic. He's more of a quiet leader. Guys can lead without the C (see Willie yelling at Mitch), unless we trade JT, why wouldn't he be captain?No way they "strip" him of the captaincy. However, they could mutually agree that it's time to pass the torch or WE, nothing wrong with that. But I also agree that I'm not sure Matthews is the ideal "captain type" so there is that. If it was me, I'd try to signs Domi long term and make him the captin, I think he'd be great! But most likely JT will be captain for at least one more year, JMHO.
I'm one who doesn't love BT, but he'll be fine. He'll make mistakes (as he already has), but I think he'll get some things right (as he also already has). I don't love that we're settling for fine, but it also might be good enough given the starting point he has. It's a ridiculously good team, better than the one he built in Calgary, so if he does/can trade someone like Marner, he should get a really good return. And he's not going to humiliate anyone (that's a good thing), that's not his style. Anything he does will be with respect to the players involved and it'll be as quiet as it can be (also a good thing).
When I look at his previous history, that's what scares me. He doesn't fall out of love with players, he's botched some major signings (both in signing guys for too long, too much, and NMCs, and by letting them walk away for nothing). I don't blame him for the Tkachuk thing, he wanted out, so he was handcuffed in the trade and was likely always going to lose it, but then botched the signings of the guys coming back. The last bit is troubling. The fact they are trying to dismantle everything he's done is troubling, too. His teams also never really did much. Lots of missed playoffs, lots of first round exits, never past the second round, but a couple of strong regular seasons. Sound familiar?
Either way, he'll be fine. We're not going to be a disaster of a team because of him, he's too conservative for that. We also might not win because of him either, but I'm not convinced we can't.
It'll be fine.
So people were making fun of Matthews not laying when he got pulled by the Dr's for a suspected concussion. Shame these folks will never admit how out of line they were
Good one……..Because they need a hard cap to support hockey in Arizona. Hey, wait....
You're filling a lot of gaps there. They still didn't explain why the highest paid player in the world couldn't play in the playoffs. They said "head injury" in game 4, and "virus" (HockeyVirus?) after game 2. They're being purposefully vague about this. Why?
Actions speak louder than words, now we wait………Overall, I’m happy with what was said in this presser. That was very close to saying we’re blowing this shit heap sky high.
Will they actually do anything? That’s another question.
Yup,I did not hear:
"We believe in this group"
"Trust the process"
"We were just one single goal from advancing"
"It's unfortunate that injuries affected our good work"
"Skilled players are so hard to find"
Did we get the Book of Mormon in return?Yeah they traded Mitch and his dad to Utah. We had to retain on Paul.
What do you need? A Dr to come out and give a full health history complete with all test results?
He was sick, played through it and it impacted his ability to perform at 100%. Then he took a hit and the Dr pulled him for a suspected concussion. What could you possibly need to know more about that?
His time in Calgary is incredibly troubling, I agree. We're a lot better than they were though. He'd really have to do something drastic for us to not make the playoffs, it'd have to be real bad. I don't think he's that type and the guys we have on the longest terms are good guys to have locked up. Like worst case he makes changes that have us make the playoffs and lose in the first round.My worry with him is that Calgary is not fine, and they started as fine, so there is potential that it comes out very bad here.
Things can get worse here.
Hoping to not have to talk about how promising Minten and Cowan are from December onward every year.
Not saying it'll happen... his history just makes me nervous.
If Marner is traded, it will be before the season starts. Won't happen in-season, and certainly not at the trade deadline.Absolutely it has to be now